Commentary: Czech philosopher Daniel Kroupa has crossed the line, or: What is racism?
Even a master carpenter can injure himself, and that has just happened to the philosopher Daniel Kroupa in his commentary for Czech Radio entitled "Carefully against Racism." In an otherwise good exploration of current issues, he has committed a foul, most likely due to little knowledge of his subject matter.
Kroupa has written, among other things, the following: "I dare say that the vast majority of our [i.e., Czech] people are not bothered if their neighbors are of Romani origin, but are bothered if those neighbors behave in the way they see them behaving during visits or in the television footage from the so-called excluded localities inhabited by Romani people. They are not, therefore, bothered by race, but by unacceptable, callous behavior that sparks an aversion which may be exaggerated, but is understandable - and which is not racism, but could easily become racism if some zealots mistake it for racism."
Kroupa should not have "dared" in this direction. I have been involved with this issue for 30 years as a journalist, a publicist, and a member of the nonprofit organization ROMEA, so I dare say that I know something more about this than he does.
While the expression "majority society" may be frequently used - which in and of itself excludes minorities - in reality we live in one society, together. Also, nobody doubts that there are some Romani individuals whom nobody wants as neighbors here - not even their fellow Roma.
I have heard, more than once, from local Romani residents in excluded localities (where people actually do live in social exclusion) that they don't want to live next door to this or that family, or next to Romani people who have just relocated into the locality. However, those were judgments about specific individuals - and in exactly such a way, many Czechs and Roma would also not want to live next door to some individual "gadje" [non-Roma] because of their lifestyles.
This is clear. However, most of the time, among whites in the Czech Republic who don't want Romani neighbors, what I have encountered is pure racism.
The reason these non-Roma reject Roma is, first and foremost, the fact that they are Romani. I have actually heard many expressions like "cikáni to the gas chambers", "bury them alive", "burn them out", "black swine", "colas", "hoses", "brownCzechs", etc. from these supposed "non-racists".
In addition, naturally, there are also Czech people who have allowed themselves to be influenced by a single example of Romani behavior they experienced during a visit, or who are being manipulated by the clamorous anti-Romani campaigns in the media here. Among them are people who actually are not racists, just as there are racists among them for whom the anti-Romani media campaign, or the example experienced during a visit, have merely confirmed what they already believed.
I dare say, therefore, on the basis of my many years of experience, that most of those who do not want to live next door to Romani people in the Czech Republic are racists. The very fact that they generalize from the behavior of some individuals to all Roma as a whole is proof of that.
It is dangerous to describe this aversion in the way that Kroupa now has, because by doing so, he is relativizing racism. I do greatly appreciate him for what he has done in the past, he has written a great deal that is brave and useful - but, he also should know that the kind of audacity he has attempted must be filtered through a deeper knowledge of this issue, not just on the basis of one's own feelings and impressions.
- Commentary: Romani actors should boycott Czech cop show over antigypsyist content
- Commentary: CNN Prima begins its Czech-language broadcasting with stereotypes about Romani people
- Commentary: Which Czech media outlets can we take seriously?
- Commentary: Time for a European Union Army
- Commentary by Czech MEP Zdechovský: Roma need work, not welfare!
- Commentary: Czech Interior Ministry is realizing ultra-nationalist politician is becoming a monster
- Commentary: Czech President spouts reassuring nonsense to ultra-nationalists
- Commentary: Truth vs. oligarchy, populism and xenophobia
- Commentary: Czech ultra-right politicians singing in harmony, and Russia likes it
- Commentary: Is the Czech PM just a liar, or is he also paranoid?
- Commentary: Czech Republic, Slovakia must compensate the victims of forced sterilization while they are still alive
- Commentary: Czech Social Democrats have to choose between democracy and racism
- Commentary: Four years for terrorism is a mockery - and others should have been tried
- Commentary: Actual risk now exists that deniers of the Holocaust of the Roma could join the Czech Government
- Commentary: Roma Pride and listening to each other
- Czech court orders director of housing corporation to apologize to Romani community member for abusive remarks
- EU Fundamental Rights Agency and OSCE say governments must deliver aid to Roma affected by COVID-19 pandemic
- Jarmila Balážová: What does the stormy debate in the Czech Republic about the TV series featuring Romani performers show us?
- Vojtěch Lavička: Czech TV show featuring Romani guys in drag is low "humor" of the fifth-rate category
- European Court of Human Rights finds Slovakia failed to properly investigate police brutality against Romani children
- Czech ecumenical service sends wishes of good fortune and good health to Romani people on their day
- Czech activist on 8 April: the Romani position in society is deteriorating, zero results from the financing invested
- Czech actors send greetings to Romani people for 8 April, World Roma Day
- Zeljko Jovanovic: The New Roma Politics of Self-Determination and Unity
- Czech court finally rules football fans' actions during attack on Black man should be considered misdemeanors, not felonies
- Czech actress accused by fellow Instagrammers of racism for her comments about Black people on an American beach
- Czech census official tells ROMEA TV all identifying information will be removed from census forms to guarantee anonymity