Czech Constitutional Court rules against hatred on the Internet in case involving threats against children
The Czech Constitutional Court has ruled that in serious cases the criminal law can be used to combat hate speech on the Internet in a democratic society and that it is necessary to do so. In a brief resolution, the court has rejected a complaint from a man who wrote hateful commentary underneath a photograph of first-graders from a school in Teplice.
The man was convicted and sentenced to 16 months in prison, suspended for three years. The order rejecting his constitutional complaint is publicly available in the court's database.
Arab and Romani children, for the most part, were shown in the photograph as attending the first grade at the Plynárenská Primary School. "They're from the Plynárenská ["Gasworks"] Primary School. The solution is obvious," Vítězslav Kroupa commented beneath a photograph of the class on Facebook.
According to a recent Supreme Court verdict, his commentary was hate speech and can neither be considered "black humor" nor defended by his right to freedom of expression. Kroupa was referring to the annihilation of "undesirable ethnic groups" in the gas chambers, the same way the Nazis systematically put Jewish and Romani people to death during the Second World War, the court has ruled.
In the constitutional complaint, the defense reiterated that the comment was intended as a joke, that it was harmless and, moreover, that it was even allegedly "socially necessary", as it drew attention to the cultural and "civilizational" differences among people. The constitutional complaint called the comment a "rational", still-admissible expression of "political dissent".
According to the Constitutional Court, however, the judiciary has explained in detail and logically that this was hate speech, i.e., a statement aimed at inciting hatred, specifically against children of other than Czech ethnicity. "Hate speech on the Internet, as one of the types of hate speech, needs to be combated in a democratic society, in serious cases through the criminal law as well," the resolution says.
Kroupa was also convicted of posting images of a German Imperial eagle holding a Nazi swastika and of the Nazis Hermann Göring and Adolf Hitler to social media. The photo of Hitler with his right arm raised in the Nazi salute was supplemented by the commentary "Beautiful White Dreams, Friends".
- New education portal about cyber hate launches and welcomes your input
- Czech Police charge dozens of online haters for attacking medical workers as Facebook blocks French and Italian accounts campaigning against vaccination with violence
- Czech campaign online in support of LGBT+ members of the Romani community says life is "too short for us to hate our own children"
- Czech Foreign Minister: Whatever is a crime offline in terms of hate speech must be considered a crime online as well
- Czech Supreme Court upholds sentence for hate posted about non-white first-graders: Not a joke, but the promotion of Nazism
- Czech MP Okamura (SPD) to lose lower house vice-chair post because of his hatemongering, according to Civic Democratic Party member
- Radek Banga refuses interview for ROMEA TV, objects to articles published by news server Romea.cz and to hateful attacks against him on Czech social media
- "Haters Will Not Stop Us!" ROMEA launches campaign to support Romani scholarship program
- Romani Experts Discussed Hate Speech and Antigypsyism in the Media
- LIVE NOW: Second day of conference on hate speech against Roma and Sinti in the media and how to combat it
- LIVE BROADCAST TODAY AND TOMORROW: Two-day conference on hate speech against Roma and Sinti in the media and how to fight it
- Czech racists hated Vodafone Christmas ad featuring non-white children, the company objects to their online comments
- Czech Interior Ministry report finds far-right party was the "super spreader" of hate last year
- Antigypsyism and antisemitism rooted in European culture for centuries, experts discuss the causes of online hate
- Chair of the Pirate Party in the Czech Republic stands up for Romani activist assaulted by hateful attackers
- Czech court returns to case of hateful online comments about non-"white" first-graders, but witnesses fail to appear
- Czech court returns to case of hate speech online targeting non-"white" first-graders
- Czech Prosecutor General working with OSCE to prosecute hate speech more effectively
- Czech Interior Ministry: Hate speech increased in intensity last year
- Czech Regional Court returns online hate speech case about death threats against first-graders to lower court, more evidence needed
- Czech ombudswoman: Haters online frequently refuse to admit to themselves that they could be breaking the law
- Zdeněk Ryšavý: Online hate - what can we do? Welcoming remarks at the 2019 Annual Conference of the International Network against Cyber Hate (INACH)
- LIVE BROADCAST: International Conference on Antigypsyism and Hate Speech Online
- Hate Killer 3000! campaign reminds bystanders in the Czech Republic how to stand up to hate
- International Network against Cyber Hate and ROMEA hold conference on antigypsyism and online hate in Czech capital
- Czech Prosecutor General insists online hate speech is a felony, Supreme Court agrees
- Czech Police, prosecutors intensively focus on online haters, number of prosecutions rising
- Czech Police investigating hateful online comments inciting violence against Czech Radio reporter that were sparked by politician
- Czech politician appeals sentence for his hateful remarks about minorities
- Czech prosecutor appeals after court acquits online hater of saying dark-skinned first-graders should be gassed to death
- Czech candidate shocked when online haters targeted her two-year-old
- Czech doctor prioritizes registration of Romani patients and receives hateful threats from non-Roma
- Czech Police say most hate crimes last year were against Roma, number of antisemitic attacks declined
- Czech Constitutional Court finds lower instance was wrong not to consider Romani celebrity subjected to online hate an injured party
- Czech court sentences Romani man to six months in prison for hate speech against the Czech President and others
- Czech Constitutional Court rejects complaint about hateful election campaigns, but agrees they were unethical
- Czech courts convict two people for racist online hate speech about newborn, three more are under investigation
- Romani LGBT activist David Tišer on Czech state holiday: Hatemongers are representing us
- Czech court finds author of death threats against human rights defenders committed a politically-motivated hate crime
- Czech school targeted with hate over its non-white first-graders last year receives donation of laptop computers
- Amateur photo contest won with images of Romani people sparks hateful reactions on Czech internet
- Czech politician spreads hateful racist hoaxes online against dark-skinned footballers, Muslims and Roma
- Czech Police charge young woman over hateful online speech against first-graders
- Czech play focuses on hateful commentaries posted to Internet discussions - #nejsemrasista_ale
- Czech prosecutors announce first indictment in case of online hate speech against first-graders
- Czech attorney: Justice for online hate has been won in a case of racist assaults against two Romani brothers
- Czech Republic: Families of children targeted with online hate spend Christmas in the mountains thanks to generous donor
- Czech Republic: Hundreds demonstrate against meeting of anti-immigration hate parties from all over Europe
- Czech cardinal congratulates hate-mongering party on their electoral results
- Czech elections 2017: ANO wins big, SocDems down but not out, Pirates score gains as does hatemongering Okamura
- Czech Human Rights Minister says he believes his department and the Hate Free Culture campaign are "unnecessary"
- Romani singer received thousands of hateful verbal assaults, Czech Police charging two people
- New Czech documentary about neo-Nazi who still lives with his mother at age 40 and hates the world
- Czech court gives vandals of businesses in the "HateFree Zone" suspended sentences
- Czech Republic: New song "Hater" by Gipsy.cz draws attention to those who use online social networks to spread hate
- EU ministers approve plan to suppress hate on the Internet
- Czech state prosecutor indicts four people over vandalizing "HateFree" businesses
- Czech Police arrest purveyors of disinformation who hatefully threatened refugees from Ukraine, court remands them into custody
- Former Czech MP loses appeal over his hateful call to "get rid of useless people", the original sentence stands
- New handbook describes how to intervene against daily hatred and racism in the Czech Republic, Germany, Italy, Portugal and the Netherlands
- USA: Racist murderer in Buffalo, New York charged with hate crimes, faces death penalty
- Czech intelligence report on extremism mentions welfare chauvinist party as a populist, xenophobic entity once more, COVID-19 was the main focus of 2021
- EU agrees rules to regulate social media content
- Czech ex-lawmaker gets six months, suspended for one year, for his remark about the WWII-era concentration camp for Roma at Lety u Písku
- Czech Constitutional Court sides with attorney Klára Kalibová: The criminality of hateful e-mails cannot be downplayed by the courts
- Czechoslovak Romani Union: Aid to those fleeing war is our moral obligation, we reject the rhetoric of refugees "taking our jobs"
- Patrik Banga: Here we go! Some people even envy the Ukrainians their bombed-out houses!
- Czech ultra-nationalists establish political nonprofit think-tank to support "patriots"
- Jaroslav Miko: We are threatened not just by the aggressive policies and hybrid attacks of Russia, but by Czech "patriots" falling for Russian propaganda