Czech Constitutional Court upholds suspended sentence for Nazi symbol on vehicle
The Czech Constitutional Court has rejected the complaint of a driver who pasted the image of the Nazi Third Reich Eagle and swastika, i.e., a symbol of Nazi Germany, across the rear windshield of his vehicle. He was convicted, given a suspended sentence, and has appealed.
In his constitutional complaint, the man emphasized that the Nazi swastika on his vehicle had been partially obscured by a "BMW" sticker on the windshield and claimed his aim had decidedly not been to promote Nazism, but just to express his enthusiasm for BMW automobiles. "If the plaintiff actually wanted to just degrade the Nazi symbol and highlight the BMW brand, there is no choice but to state that he chose (at a minimum) a very inappropriate, unsuitable method for doing so which actually entailed criminal liability for expressing sympathy for a movement aimed at suppressing human rights and freedoms," the court's resolution, available in the judicial database, reads.
The man also did not succeed with another argument referencing the fact that the anti-Fascist movement uses the image of the Nazi swastika with a line crossed through it without anybody finding anything extremist about the depiction of the swastika in that context. The court acknowledged that the mere use of a symbol in and of itself does not meet the subjective definition of the facts that give rise to this crime - what is always decisive is the intention with which a person uses a symbol.
"The will to espouse Nazi ideas is not expressed, for example, in the case of the production of an historical film depicting that era, nor in a situation when a person is obviously expressing disagreement with that ideology through particular symbols. Nothing of the sort, however, is possible to infer in the plaintiff's case," the justices wrote.
The District Court in Kladno sentenced the man in November 2015 to half a year in prison, suspended for 12 months, and the Regional Court in Prague upheld that decision this past February, as did the Supreme Court, according to which, it is generally known what the Nazi Third Reich Eagle and swastika represent, i.e., that those symbols are connected with Nazism and that the owner of the vehicle knew that when he used the symbol. "In this case, the accused knew the meaning of the symbols used and if he publicly displayed them on his vehicle, that was an expression of sympathy for that meaning," the Supreme Court ruled.
- Czech court sentences youth to four months in prison for threatening to shoot man on Facebook
- Czech court overturns fine against attorney who objected to expert by alleging he was Jewish
- Czech court reopens trial of promotion of neo-Nazism, now in its sixth year
- Czech court acquits defendant of disseminating radical Islamic book
- Czech court rejects Interior Ministry lawsuit over gallows mock-ups
- Czech court says police not responsible for death of Romani man
- European Court of Human Rights: Slovakia failed to investigate Roma youth's allegations of police brutality
- Czech Constitutional Court to review town's forced relocation of Romani residents
- Czech court says police must further investigate ultra-right activist's hate speech about Muslims
- Slovak Interior Ministry says police raid on Romani settlement was correct, victims appeal to Constitutional Court
- Czech court overturns fine against club for refusing Romani patrons admission after errors found in investigation
- Czech Republic: Autonomous Social Center Klinika is again open to the public, court overturns preliminary injunction
- Czech court says property owner must give squatter representative the keys to the Klinika building, for now
- Czech MEPs welcome European Commission lawsuit against Austria over different allowances for non-expatriate children of EU workers
- Czech Supreme Administrative Court upholds homeless Romani family's appeal of eviction, returns case to Regional Court
- Czech Constitutional Court agrees with politician who sued over nickname ridiculing him in the press
- Romani children in the Czech Republic still frequently assessed as mentally disabled and educated separately
- Scottish court convicts traffickers of exploiting young women
- Czech producer of items with portraits of totalitarians adds war criminals, contemporary figures to product line
- Czech court to try Islamophobes who attacked Muslim couple in a park last year
- Germany: Alcohol banned at neo-Nazi festival, some locals also bought up all the beer to keep it out of neo-Nazi hands
- Czech gunman who fired warning shots over Romani children at summer camp has his sentence reduced to a fine
- Former secretary for Czech ultranationalist party rejects indictment over his remarks about minorities
- Czech lower courts consider online comment calling for asylum-seekers to be set on fire a misdemeanor, Supreme Court to rule now
- German court says immigrant Romani pupil incorrectly assigned to "special school" deserves compensation