Czech judge sanctioned for articles about migrants in bad taste
A disciplinary panel of the Supreme Administrative Court (Nejvyšší správní soud - NSS) has officially cautioned a judge in Liberec, Czech Republic, Miloš Zbránek, for publishing two articles online. According to the panel, both of the pieces depicted migrants and the staff of nonprofit organizations in a grossly defamatory and non-objective way that crosses the line of decency and good taste.
The action brought against the judge mentioned one other text he had authored, but the panel found that piece did not necessitate sanctions. The written caution in the judge's record is the least severe form of sanction possible in a disciplinary proceeding.
Zbránek considers the panel's assessment of his writing to be subjective and previously stated in his defense that satire is not supposed to be "gracious or merciful". He did not attend the hearing on 6 June when the decision was announced.
Judge Miloš Zbránek: Excerpt from his earlier antigypsyist online writings
A matter of taste
If the two articles in question had been written by somebody who was not a judge, then the panel said they could never have become grounds for an intervention by a public power such as the court. While the opinions expressed there are extreme, still they do not espouse a hateful ideology and they do not call on anybody to do anything illegal.
Zbránek, of course, is a judge, which means he should be more restrained and make sure he does not subvert the dignity of his judicial office and thereby place the public's trust in the independence of the judiciary at risk. The profession of judge involves many restrictions, but judges in the Czech Republic are still allowed to dedicate themselves to artistic, literary and publicist endeavors.
The panel upheld the legal action against Zbránek with respect to his articles entitled "Report on Wandering into Germany" and "Letter to a Disoriented Asylum-Seeker", but not with respect to his article entitled "Report of the European Commissioner on the State of Human Rights in Muslim Lhota". The panel said the latter piece had been obvious satire, avoided vulgarities, and was based on actual events.
The panel emphasized that it is defensible for a judge to write satire. The two pieces on the topic of refugees, however, were considered by the panel to come too close to crossing the line of decency and good taste.
"In some instances the pieces even cross that line," presiding Judge Radovan Havelec said. The decision of the panel mentions the pieces' generalizing depictions of refugees and their pointless use of vulgarisms as the straw that broke the camel's back.
Zbránek works at the Liberec branch of the Regional Court, where he handles the business law agenda and where his supervisors have no objections about his actual job performance. The president of that court, Luboš Dörfl, has, however, previously called upon him to be more moderate in his writing.
When Zbránek's publishing activity did not improve, his superior filed a disciplinary action against him. The panel reviewed it on 26 May.
Zbránek would not actually even confirm at that time whether he was the author of the articles in question. The panel, however, considered it beyond dispute that he had in fact authored them.
Dörfl has welcomed the disciplinary panel's decision. "I appreciate that in the panel's justification there was a detailed discussion of how to assess a judge's publication activity and what lines a judge should not cross," Dörfl said.
The head of the Liberec Regional Court said he does not believe the limits of judicial ethics are firmly established in the Czech Republic yet and said they can be gradually clarified through similar decisions. In addition to insulting refugees and Romani people, Zbránek's texts to date have also insulted gay people.
He has also not hesitated to insult ombudsperson Anna Šabatová (see the excerpt above). His pieces have been criticized by Czech Justice Minister Robert Pelikán (ANO), who said that some seemed homophobic and Islamophobic to him, which could call into question the judge's impartiality during disputes in which members of those minorities are involved.
Zbránek's case is an isolated one. Disciplinary actions usually concern delays of proceedings and similar offenses.
There is a certain similarity between his case and that of Prague Judge Kamil Kydalka. According to a verdict handed down against Kydalka last year by another disciplinary panel, the judge erred when he expressed his opinion about a local political struggle ongoing in the town of Mnichovice u Prahy, where he owns a summer home.
In that case, however, the panel refrained from imposing sanctions. Bringing the disciplinary action against the judge was in and of itself considered punishment enough.
- Czech Justice Minister wants judge whose writing insults gays, refugees and Roma to resign
- Commentary: When judges go in-depth
- Death of Czech judge remains unclarified
- Czech judge who sentenced Vítkov arsonists has been murdered
- Slovak Prosecutor: Fascist pandemic is just as dangerous as COVID-19, trial of extreme politician begins tomorrow
- Germany: Halle terrorist charged with double murder and 68 counts of attempted murder
- Two men in Czech Republic indicted for approving of neo-Nazi terrorism in Christchurch, New Zealand
- Czech town puts "container housing" for Romani-inhabited locality on hold, former ombudswoman recommended cancelling it altogether
- EUobserver on how anti-Roma racism is being exploited during the COVID-19 pandemic
- Czech court returns to case of hate speech online targeting non-"white" first-graders
- Regional coalition of Romani representatives calls on Czech ombudsman to apologize for his remarks about Romani people
- Forced sterilizations in Europe and the USA and their consequences for today
- Czech Prosecutor General working with OSCE to prosecute hate speech more effectively
- Anna Šabatová's term as Czech Public Defender of Rights ends: "I did what was within my power to do"
- Czech bookstore fires clerk for racially insulting Romani colleague on social media
- Czech Prosecutor General appeals to continue case against eight members of the neo-Nazi "National Resistance"