Czech Labor Minister wants parents to lose housing benefits if children are truant, Pirate MP says that is monstrous
According to the daily Právo, Czech Labor and Social Affairs Minister Jana Maláčová is planning to punish the parents of truant schoolchildren by stripping them of their housing benefits. That would be the outcome of the revision to the welfare system she recently presented to MPs on the Social Committee.
"We are proposing a maximum limit of 100 missed hours of instruction per semester that are not due to medical reasons," the minister told the daily, adding that she anticipates debate about the issue with the Education Ministry. Failure to fulfill their obligation to make sure children attend compulsory education can already be punished today by depriving parents of their subsistence benefit or their parental contribution benefit.
Similar restrictions are also included in a bill on the state providing advances on child support to one parent when the other does not meet their obligations, but children's truancy has not yet been associated with parents' eligibility for housing benefits. In addition to associating housing benefits with the regular school attendance of the children of those otherwise entitled to the benefits, the ministry is also planning to combine the existing housing allowance and housing supplement into a single benefit.
"We must send a clear signal that what is normal is to work and send children to school, that is the desirable state of affairs. Whoever does not send their children to school is robbing them of their future," the minister said in justification of her draft bill.
The revision to the benefits also counts on increasing the amount of money that cannot be subjected to collections so that members of low-income groups who are facing collections will find legal employment to be remunerative despite their wages being garnished, although the ministry is also proposing extending the time during which those who refuse to cooperate with the Labor Office will be ineligible for such benefits from six months to nine. Several nonprofit organizations are criticizing the minister's proposals, reproaching them for being too strict and warning that they could further deteriorate the situations of impoverished people.
"This revision of social benefits is perceived in large part as a repressive measure. I have been showered with criticism for being anti-social, but if people do not make efforts on their own, we will never move forward," the minister told the Social Committee in the lower house.
"The number of excluded localities has tripled recently," she told MPs. She did admit, however, that repression alone has never successfully tackled poverty, and is therefore proposing to combine it with intensive social work with clients.
"Social work is the key to addressing this entire issue," she said. The Education Ministry is refusing to express its view of the proposals for now.
"The Ministry of Education, Youth and Sport will not comment on or critique the proposals of other ministries through the media," Education Ministry spokesperson Aneta Lednová told the daily. The coalition Government will be discussing the proposals in the future.
"I don't know this bill, but the number of parents excusing their children from attendance is growing even in regions such as Central Bohemia. School principals have turned to me and want a solution for this," Czech MP Kateřina Valachová (Czech Social Democratic Party - ČSSD), herself a former Education Minister, told the daily.
"I think it's important to begin with the causes of this and to arrange for children's attendance," Valachová said, adding that she will be discussing the issue with the Labor Minister. In the regions with the highest number of excluded localities and socially vulnerable people, such as the Ústecký or Karlovy Vary Regions, 14.5 % of pupils never complete their primary school attendance.
Czech MP Olga Richterová, the first Vice-Chair of the Pirate Party, has taken a critical stance toward the prepared changes. She called the bill monstrous.
"A limit of 100 hours of [non-medical] absence per child as a punishment for the entire family will not aid this problem without addressing its causes," she told the daily. "Sometimes children actually don't go to school because they didn't get up in time, but sometimes they go because they wouldn't be able to buy a snack or lunch there, or because they don't have any clean clothes to wear."
"Sometimes children do go to school but fall asleep during class because they live in residential hotels that are noisy at night where they've been bitten by bedbugs," Richterová emphasized, reminding the daily that while a school can currently request that a doctor explain a child's absence if it has lasted more than three days, doctors are not obligated to confirm why a child was absence. According to Richterová, the bill will lead to disputes between doctors and parents, as physicians are not clearly required to issue explanations of absence for children and many already refuse to do so.
The chair of the TOP 09 party, Markéta Pekarová Adamová, agrees with tightening the rules. "I agree with this, but in parallel to tightening the benefits it is absolutely crucial to work with the families in which these problematic phenomena appear so that the measure doesn't result in a higher number of children being taken away from their families and placed in foster care, including institutions," Pekarová Adamová explained.
- Czech Government Agency for Social Inclusion publishes analysis of segregation in primary schools
- Magdalena Karvayová on estimating the distribution of Roma in the schools: Data are important to desegregation
- Czech mayor heading new commission to design changes to housing benefits
- Prague City Council disagrees with Czech bill to consolidate two housing benefits into one
- Platform for Social Housing calls on Czech Labor Minister to withdraw her cancellation of housing benefits
- Czech research finds that majority must change its approach to Romani people in order to improve the situation in the schools
- Czech Labor and Social Affairs Ministry plans to abolish existing housing benefits
- Regional Roma association opposes housing benefit-free zones in yet another Czech city
- Czech Government Agency for Social Inclusion criticizes housing benefit-free zones
- Karel Karika: Benefit-free zones are absurd, the populists are abusing their power
- Yet another Czech city announces its entire territory to be a housing benefit-free zone
- Czech Govt Agency for Social Inclusion does not support housing benefit-free zones in Liberec
- Yet another Czech town bans housing benefits, opposition politician and Romani NGO object
- Czech Republic: 88 cities in 12 regions plan to ban housing benefits in specific zones
- Czech Christian Democrats, SocDems want to stop the use of vouchers in material distress benefits
- Civil society members of Czech Govt Roma Council leave meeting in protest against housing benefit-free zones
- Czech Social Democrats would withdraw controversial plan to further restrict housing benefits
- Czech village wants to stop housing benefits altogether, plans to buy up apartment buildings
- Czech Labor Minister says lower housing benefits will drive down rents, experts say it will destroy social housing policy
- Czech ministers want to speak with Roma about truancy
- Truancy widespread among Romany children
- Slovak project where Roma build their own homes seems more feasible in village setting, for now
- Czech local zones to cancel housing benefits create more poverty, the biggest one is Ústí nad Labem
- Czech housing benefit rules become more strict as of 1 July
- Commentary: Czech Labor Minister's bill to change housing benefits will make life worse for those who need aid the most
- Amnesty International criticizes Czech discrimination of Roma, Public Defender of Rights says AI is "biased"
- Czech Labor and Social Affairs Minister has plan to re-open social services
- Czech Labor Minister tells ROMEA TV the crucial priority is to prevent mass unemployment because of COVID-19
- Slovak Plenipotentiary for Roma says Govt decision not to deliver benefits to Romani settlements is inhumane
- Czech Caritas: Debts cause school dropout, welfare reforms will not improve attendance
- Vladimír Leško of the Association of Romani Entrepreneurs and Guilds in the Czech Republic: Let's turn welfare recipients into taxpayers
- Czech teachers disagree with proposal to deprive parents of children with high absenteeism of their social benefits
- Czech Govt Roma Council sharply criticizes Labor Minister's repressive proposals on housing benefits