Czech politician not to be compensated over nickname, courts say reasonable use of it is allowed
Czech MP Tomio Okamura ("Freedom and Direct Democracy" - SPD), a vice-chair of the Czech lower house, has failed with his legal appeal over a dispute caused by the use of a nickname for him, "Pitomio" [loose translation - "Tomidiot"] by the Czech weekly magazine Reflex. Okamura appealed a previous court ruling that instructed the magazine to apologize to the politician for using the nickname in two articles in 2013 but did not award him compensation, and the judiciary has at a more general level admitted that it is possible to use the "Pitomio" nickname as part of justified criticism of the public figure.
In March the Czech Supreme Court made its decision and returned the file at the end of April to the first-instance court, judges from which have not yet made the full wording of their reasoning public. Markéta Puci, spokesperson for the Municipal Court in Prague, the first-instance venue for the case, told the Czech News Agency that judges refused to rule on part of the appeal and agreed to rule on the rest in order to reject it.
Both the Municipal Court and the High Court in Prague have emphasized that expressive, unflattering expressions should not be used by the media against politicians tendentiously. Nevertheless, if such expressions are part of a legitimate criticism of specific attitudes or remarks, their use is possible.
In the case of Okamura, the judiciary took into account the politician's own media presentations, noting that he makes provocative appearances, promotes political incorrectness, enjoys choosing strong language himself, and does his best to be controversial. "This term is expressively unflattering, but it is not a priori vulgar, and de facto support for it can be found in the article's content, which thoroughly describes why certain ideas of the plaintiff's are potentially socially dangerous and why, therefore, it is possible to consider them 'balderdash', using a certain dose of journalistic shorthand," news server Lidovky.cz previously quoted the appeals court decision as saying.
The controversial articles were published by Reflex in 2013. In October of that year Okamura became an MP for the "Dawn of Direct Democracy" party.
Okamura is currently an MP and chair of the SPD movement. The nickname "Pitomio" has been used to refer to him from time to time over the last few months by other media than Reflex, such as the Euro periodical or the Lidové noviny newspaper.
- Hundreds commemorate Romani victims of WWII-era camp, criticize Czech politicians for Holocaust denial
- Czech court upholds limits on media using nicknames for politicians
- Commentary: CNN Prima begins its Czech-language broadcasting with stereotypes about Romani people
- Czech Constitutional Court agrees with politician who sued over nickname ridiculing him in the press
- Czech journalists find the man behind the Aeronet disinformation server
- Czech President's nominee for ombudsman says he would not deal with discrimination against Roma if chosen because that's what the courts are for
- Commentary: Which Czech media outlets can we take seriously?
- Czech court again acquits youths accused of assaulting man because of his skin color, prosecutor may appeal
- For a third time, Slovak court acquits police of brutalizing Romani children a decade ago, prosecutor appealing
- Czech trial begins of brutal, allegedly racially-motivated assault by non-Romani adults on Romani children
- Czech politician who relies on hatred ties himself in knots over the ultra-right terrorism in Germany
- Patrik Banga: Social media is depriving us of context and driving us all crazy
- Czech right-wing extremist and 9/11 apologist cozies up to new movement run by son of former President
- Czech ultrachauvinist shares satire online - without getting the joke