Czech study finds publication for teachers defended status quo and opposed inclusion
The EDUin organization has published a study by researcher Dušan Klapko from Masaryk University in Brno about the discourse used by the publication "Teachers News" (Učitelské noviny) when discussing the issue of inclusive education. The study finds that from 2010-2014, that publication defended the interests of the "practical" schools and opposed inclusion.
The study found that "Teachers News" dedicated more space to those opposed to either partial or total inclusion. Proponents of inclusion, which the paper identified as the Education Ministry and nonprofit organizations, were given very little space.
The opponents of inclusion who presented their opinions in the paper said they considered it necessary to uphold the selective nature of the Czech schools because, in their view, it "better meets the specific needs of Romani children". According to the study, opponents of inclusion also said they believed problems with educating Romani pupils were caused by the environment such pupils came from, and they ascribed the characteristics they viewed as causing such problems to the Romani environment generally.
The study also found that those opposed to inclusion "construe the cause of the problem in educating Romani pupils as being the low value of education in that environment, parental neglect, and the reproduction of bad social role models." According to the study, those opposed to inclusion do not believe it is possible to achieve any significant change in this regard, and that inclusion would be inexpedient, because it would just lead to integration that "would have the character of coexistence on the school bench (adjacent to each other, but not together)", which paradoxically might intensify segregation because the number of private, elite schools could grow as a consequence.
The opponents of inclusion who wrote for "Teachers News", according to the study, also believed that proponents of inclusion did not have sufficient expertise or practice in education and did not know the environment deeply. Klapko found that the newspaper repeatedly impugned the pedagogical expertise of nonprofit sector representatives, charging them with being motivated by greed and with exaggerating the problem politically, and blaming the Education Ministry for being too weak to resist their pressure.
The researcher sees the origin of the clashes between those on opposite sides of the issue as coming from their different perspectives on how to solve the problem, perspectives that mainly stem from the different practical experiences of those in each camp. He reaches the conclusion that each side is pursuing its own version of a similar vision about equal opportunities in education and social justice.
- Czech NGO whose head spreads hatred against Muslims and refugees will continue to work with Govt Agency for Social Inclusion
- Czech Govt Agency for Social Inclusion reviews local group working with Romani children after its head attacks the HateFree Culture initiative
- Czech Govt Agency for Social Inclusion's dilemma: What to do with haters of "HateFree" who work with Romani children?
- Czech President says he vetoed education amendment because of inclusion
- Czech Senate approves education amendment in full, opponents of inclusion failed to convince them otherwise
- Czech Constitutional Court receives motion to abolish inclusion in amendment to Schools Act
- Patrik Banga: Inclusion? Definitely yes!
- Czech experts say teachers do not believe state will support inclusion
- Czech principal: Children have the least problem with inclusion because they have yet to absorb adult prejudice
- Czech parent group in favor of inclusion says the state's approach is the biggest obstacle
- Czech Education Minister rejects mayors' calls to delay inclusion
- Commentary by Karel Holomek: Special educators' lobby has tried to convince us for years that inclusion can't happen yet
- Czech Education Ministry responds on basic timeline for inclusion preparations
- Commentary: Are the Czech schools at risk of chaos next year? Experts, teachers doubt schools are prepared for inclusion
- Some Czech schools report inclusion already happening, Romani pupils achieving average results
- Czech Human Rights Minister says EU allocating CZK 10 billion to inclusion
- Czech Gov't Agency for Social Inclusion director says all-Romani classes are unfortunate, media misquote him
- Czech Police charge two men for publishing racist content about mass killing last year, Pirate Party and ROMEA filed reports against them
- Commentary: Senator infamous for antigypsyist remarks about the "cikánská question" joins regional party in the Czech Republic
- Romani actor to appear in latest installment of antigypsyist Czech film series made by former 'special school' teacher
- Czechs to protest COVID-19 measures on national holiday tomorrow - including neo-Nazis reviving antisemitic tropes
- Czech national audit says schools were not prepared for inclusion and local governments are not drawing funds for it in socially excluded localities
- Czech Senate candidates use rhetoric about "inadaptables" and xenophobic tropes in second round battle
- Bulgaria: Scandal over EU-financed training to detect alleged "radicalization" of Roma, activists say money was used to boost anti-Romani sentiment
- COMMENTARY: Romani actors should refuse to perpetuate stereotypes in Czech television programs
- Commentary: Work on antisemitism by US professor reminds us of antigypsyism in the Czech Republic today
- Commentary: Czech journalists stoke hatred of Romani people to distract from failed pandemic response
- EP calls on EC to draft a law on the equality, inclusion and participation of Romani people and on combating antigypsyism
- Czech Education Ministry wants to end funding for assistants to thousands of disabled children, expert says this will ruin inclusive education