Czech Supreme Court overturns acquittal on publication of Hitler's speeches, wants more evidence
The Czech Supreme Court has overturned the acquittal in the case of the publication of a book of speeches by Nazi dictator Adolf Hitler in Czech translation. The case has been returned to the state prosecutor for further investigation and the accumulation of more evidence.
News server Lidovky.cz reported on the decision, which is available in full on the website of Tomáš Pecina, attorney for the Guidemedia publishing house. The appeal to the Supreme Court was filed by Supreme State Prosecutor Pavel Zeman.
The Supreme State Prosecutor did not agree with the lower courts' conclusions that publishing Hitler's speeches in this form is not criminal under applicable law. "The Supreme Court, based on a motion to appeal, overturned the verdicts at both levels and returned the matter to the state prosecutor for further investigation, finding the decision to have been premature, and ordered the finding of more evidence," Petr Malý, spokesperson for the Supreme State Prosecutor, told the Czech News Agency.
"This is about certain circumstances without which courts cannot make their decisions fairly, and those facts could and should have been clarified already during the preliminary proceedings prior to the lawsuit being filed," the Supreme Court's decision reads, mentioning as an example of missing evidence the possible connection of the defendants with extremist groups abroad or in the Czech Republic. The Supreme Court also expresses doubt over the impartiality of expert witness Jan B. Uhlíř, which Pecina called the only good news connected with the Supreme Court's decision.
"In all other respects the arcs of the prospective outcomes are not good," Pecina posted to his website about the decision. Defendants Stanislav Beer, Pavel Kamas and Lukáš Novák faced charges of approval of genocide in the Hitler speech case.
The indictment was also aimed against the publishing house itself. The Municipal Court and Regional Court in Brno acquitted all involved.
The appeals proceeding became protracted in 2015 due to an ultimately failed accusation of bias against the Supreme Court justices who were impaneled to hear the case because all three are former members of the Communist Party of Czechoslovakia. Those who contributed to the publication of Hitler's speeches were facing up to 10 years in prison if convicted.
The courts in Brno found that they had not approved of genocide and that by publishing the speeches they were just presenting historical documents to readers. The indictment had reproached the book for including accompanying texts along with the authentic speeches that did not sufficiently distance themselves from the ideas of National Socialism and from Hitler's actions and speech.
A publisher of Hitler's book Mein Kampf in the Czech Republic has also been brought to trial in the past. That publisher first received a suspended sentence but was ultimately acquitted by the Supreme Court in March 2005.
- Czech singer gets married on Hitler's birthday at a chateau where the SS were headquartered
- Germany: 750 neo-Nazis celebrate Hitler's birthday, police confiscate their materials
- Austria: Hitler impersonator arrested for appearing in the Nazi leader's home town
- Czech Republic: Five physically injured after Hitler is praised in local restaurant
- German Police say Munich shooter was an ultra-right supporter proud of sharing a birthdate with Hitler
- Admirer of Hitler and MPs who insult refugees now on Slovak legislature's Human Rights and Minorities Committee
- Austria still trying to decide what to do with Hitler's birthplace
- Commentary: Hitler was the biggest optimist
- Czech court rules publication of Hitler's speeches was legal
- Czech Police charge right-wing extremists who assaulted citizens of India
- Local Prague candidate seems to have given Nazi salute at demonstration, extremist party she is running for disavows her
- Czech appeals court reduces sentence for murder of Romani man to seven years, prosecutor calls it disproportionate, inhumane and unjust
- Slovakia: Chair of neo-Nazi party indicted for using Nazi symbols on checks
- Czech Constitutional Court rejects complaint from neo-Nazi convicted of 2012 arson
- German Police find right-wing extremists' list of 25 000 "enemies"
- German court sentences neo-Nazi to life in prison
- Ukraine: Recent pogroms against Roma costing lives around the country
- Slovakia: Man shoots at Romani groundskeepers, then hangs Nazi flag from his window, is now in custody
- Ukrainian court remands two juveniles into custody for murderous pogrom against Roma, Canada and USA condemn the racist violence
- German judge's word choice causes retrial of arson incident against asylum-seekers' shelter
- Ukraine: One Romani man killed and others injured, including child, during yet another neo-Nazi pogrom
Tags:Nazism, Neo-Nazism, Soud, Adolf Hitler
Czech local election campaign slogan: "Poison alone is not strong enough for these pests" - meaning Romani people7.9.2018 17:49
Každý diskutující musí dodržovat PRAVIDLA DISKUZE SERVERU Romea.cz. Moderátoři serveru Romea.cz si vyhrazují právo bez předchozího upozornění skrýt nevhodné příspěvky z diskuse na Romea.cz. Ty pak budou viditelné jen pro vás a vaše přátele na Facebooku. Při opakovaném porušení pravidel mohou moderátoři zablokovat zobrazování vašich příspěvků v diskusích na Romea.cz ostatním uživatelům.