Czech teachers disagree with proposal to deprive parents of children with high absenteeism of their social benefits
The Teachers' Platform (Učitelská platforma) in the Czech Republic is rejecting a Labor and Social Affairs Ministry proposal to disqualify those applying for or already receiving housing benefits if their children are absent from compulsory school attendance for more than 100 hours per semester and do not provide confirmation from a doctor that illness was the reason. Teachers' experiences in practice show it is most effective to work with the families of frequently-absent pupils in a completely different way that does not involve tactics of repression.
The proposal is also discriminatory, according to the platform, as it does not address the absenteeism problems of children whose guardians do not apply for or already receive housing benefits. The platform also does not see any actual need for this kind of legal regulation at the moment.
The current law on welfare benefits to those in material distress already allows guardians to be penalized for not making sure their children attend compulsory schooling. “This entire bill, if put into practice, is likely to exacerbate the already poor social situation of many families," explains Petra Mazancová, chairwoman of the Teachers' Platform association.
"Instead of helping to tackle the problem of low school attendance, it will throw the parents of school-aged children into situations where they are at the mercy of collections agents and even closer to a state of emergency with respect to meeting their existential needs. Such a life situation will not make such children go to school more often," Mazancová explains.
“Working with pupils from non-stimulating environments and with their parents is frequently undoubtedly very difficult. Many of the problems associated with their life situations do not have immediate, simple solutions," says Jaroslav Jirásko, head of the K.V. Rais Primary School in Lázně Bělohrad.
"However, neither repression against the parents nor resignation to the situation provide even the hint of a solution. On the contrary, it is the families of these pupils and the pupils themselves who should be the focus of the greatest educational efforts and work of schools and their staff," Jirásko says.
"Teachers who take their profession seriously should know this and should act accordingly,” the principal says. Mazancová goes on to say that "The experience of many schools trying to work with families in difficult social situations shows that such a repressive, vigorous approach often closes off the possibility of any further communication with the family and any other efforts to solve their problems."
The association chair also noted that the bill does not address the unexcused absences of children whose parents are not welfare beneficiaries. The current proposal also contradicts some of the previous materials published by the Labor and Social Affairs Ministry.
For example, one year ago, as part of a project run by the ministry, a publication was released entitled "Innovations in Working with Children and Families at Risk" which describes extensively how to work with families when truancy is an issue. That publication does not contain any repressive measures; on the contrary, it describes the needs of such children and their families and suggests procedures for addressing truancy inspired by good practice in the Czech Republic and abroad.
The Labor and Social Affairs Ministry's bill on housing allowances also plans to combine the current housing benefit and housing supplement into one allowance for which, among other things, guardians would not qualify if a child misses more than 100 hours of compulsory school over the course of six months for non-medical reasons. The Education Ministry, the Platform for Social Housing, and a number of social workers have already expressed their criticisms and are against the bill, which has also been sharply criticized by the Czech Government Council on Roma Minority Affairs.
- Young teacher describes how antigypsyism is alive and well in Czech primary education
- Jana Balážová: Not acceptable for teachers to see Romani children as a burden
- Czech Republic: Romani law student from Slovakia says feeling her teachers cared about her future was a big help to her
- Romani student Gabriela Janičová: My dream is to become a teacher
- Martin Dudi: I want to become a teacher or work with children from poor families
- Czech study finds publication for teachers defended status quo and opposed inclusion
- International experts: Friendly approach from teachers toward families essential to successful inclusive education
- Czech experts say teachers do not believe state will support inclusion
- Czech teachers can invite performances from "You, Me and Them - theater as a forum against prejudice" to their schools
- Czech university administrators, students issue statements about police banning access for students and teachers to 17 November memorial
- Czech Republic: Romani preschool teacher knows change is possible
- Commentary: Are the Czech schools at risk of chaos next year? Experts, teachers doubt schools are prepared for inclusion
- Czech research finds teachers support educating all children together
- Czech ethnology students begin strike in defense of fired teachers
- Amnesty International Czech Republic launches online manual for teachers about handling intolerance
- Czech school gives excluded children good teachers and tablets
- Author raising a Romani child says Czech Public Defender of Rights is racist and evil is slowly winning
- Czech Caritas: Debts cause school dropout, welfare reforms will not improve attendance
- Hungarian PM announces "national consultation" about whether to compensate Romani families whose children were educated in segregated settings
- Vladimír Leško of the Association of Romani Entrepreneurs and Guilds in the Czech Republic: Let's turn welfare recipients into taxpayers
- Robert Olah, Romani university student in the Czech Republic, on personal motivation and nonprofit support
- Czech Govt Roma Council sharply criticizes Labor Minister's repressive proposals on housing benefits
- Czech Labor and Social Affairs Minister's housing benefit reforms criticized from all sides
- European Court of Human Rights finds Slovak authorities did not properly investigate police brutality against Romani boy
- Czech Labor Minister wants parents to lose housing benefits if children are truant, Pirate MP says that is monstrous
- Romani children in the Czech Republic still frequently assessed as mentally disabled and educated separately
- Czech EdMin proposes new system to harmonize differences among educational advisory centers' recommendations
- Czech mayor who failed to tackle "white flight" publicly curses nonprofits and Romani people, Agency for Social Inclusion calls for dialogue