Film about Czechoslovak experiment with Romani children wins best documentary from Olomouc Film Academy
A documentary film by Czech Television, "Suppressed Letters" (Zatajené dopisy) about an experimental school for Romani children in 1950s Czechoslovakia, has won the prize for best Czech popular science documentary from the Academia Film Olomouc. At the beginning of the experiment, children attended the boarding school voluntarily, but later attended after being forcibly taken away from their families on the presumption that their ties with their parents would be broken.
The jury expressed appreciation in particular for the filmmakers' efforts to show the ambiguity of this under-researched topic while also bringing it to the public with the appropriate urgency. However, the surprisingly non-confrontational character of the film has raised more questions than it has managed to provide answers.
"Our documentary does not offer a simple schematic, it's not black-and-white. It's not a documentary about Romani people, to a degree it's about all of us, about how we do our best to cope with racism and xenophobia, and also about how, by building ghettos, we create them anew," said creative producer Lenka Poláková, according to the press spokesperson for Czech Television, adding that "I am very please that the AFO jury chose this gentle, subtle film, which forces us to reflect."
Critical opinions, however, have also been voiced to the effect that the film lacks both balance and the voices of those who were forced to pay the highest price when their children were forcibly removed from their families because of the vision of cultivating "proper members of socialist society". "It is not intended as a confrontation, although the complexity and seriousness of the topic would have made that appropriate. After all, when the 90-year-old respected educator is telling a story that, for propaganda reasons, he edited back in the 1950s already, it would be appropriate to have someone in the film opposing 'his truth' at that moment," writes Lenka Jandáková in her review of the film for Romea.cz.
"Dědič, the main designer of this experiment, was motivated by a desire to prove to what was then a socialist society that Romani people are educable - as long as the influence of their Romani upbringing is eliminated. In his diary he called the children who had been removed from their parents 'material for our workshop on humanity'. In the spirit of the slogan 'everything for the idea', Dědič did not hesitate to use both physical and psychological violence, which meant censoring, falsifying or suppressing correspondence between the children and their parents, using bureaucratic tactics to prevent parents from visiting (the school was located in the Boletice military area, which required official permission to enter), and even punching one mother in the face when she was defending the children who did not want to leave her side," Jandáková writes.
According to a press release from Czech Television, the director, Tomáš Kudrna, originally did not have film festival ambitions as part of his interest in making the documentary. "We wanted primarily to do good work under the given conditions. Be that as it may, ever since our premiere at One World there has been interest in the film from other festivals. That may be because we have succeeded in conceiving of Romani subject matter in a new way that is not cliché. The award from the Academia Film Olomouc just confirms that the topic of Romani education is more than necessary, it's alive - it is being discussed a great deal, and 'Suppressed Letters' is contributing important stories and testimonies to that discussion," he said.
The so-called Květušínská School functioned during the 1950s in the Boletice military area. The subject of its experiment was Romani children and the question of whether they could be incorporated into the socialist education system.
The film follows 11-year-old Karolínka, the granddaughter of a pupil at the school, as she researches its history. She asks questions of her neighbors and relatives and gradually learns that while the pupils may have thrived academically due to the work of their teachers, many paid a high price for it which traumatizes them to this day.
The children were removed from their family environments as part of the experiment and, soon after it was created, the school began to function as a boarding school and children's home which the children's parents were forbidden to enter. The documentary about it was broadcast by Czech Television on the occasion of International Romani Day and is available to watch free of charge through Czech Television's online iVysílání program.
- Documentary film review: "Suppressed Letters", about a Czechoslovak experiment with Romani children
- Documentary shows Roma from Slovak settlements singing with non-Romani musicians
- Documentary films by Roma about Roma screen in Vienna
- Interview with director of documentary film about Romani girls
- Will Czech documentary about Romani activist unite, or divide?
- Czech director of documentary about quintuplets: There is truth on both sides
- Documentary film review: "All My Children"
- Czech documentary by Roma about Roma celebrates success at French Institute
- Czech festival gives highest prize to documentary about racist murders of Roma in Hungary
- Romedia film nominated for Al-Jazeera's International Documentary Film Festival
- Documentary about blockade of neo-Nazi march in Brno, Czech Republic premieres next month
- Documentary about three Roma women in politics premieres at Khamoro Festival in Prague
- Integration through children's eyes: Documentary film "Our School" shows the snags in desegregation
- "Scars of Racism": CNN documentary gently shows the cost of indifference to neo-Nazism
- Documentary on the attempted neo-Nazi pogrom at Janov
- Documentary films on SEE social, political and human rights issues
- Educator Martin Kaleja: From the Romani settlements in Slovakia to the Czech academic world
- European Roma Institute for Arts and Culture offering year-long paid internship in Berlin, Germany
- Czech Republic sees eighth BARUVAS program meeting for Romani students
- Czech EdMin delaying changes to decree on inclusion that NGOs protested, review is underway
- Magdalena Karvayová: Romani children in the Czech schools are still segregated, we can change that
- Czech Education Minister disagrees with free lunches for all primary schoolchildren
- Czech Public Defender of Rights recommends 10 measures to improve Romani integration into mainstream schools with non-Romani children
- Czech amendment to school regulations is a step backward, actual needs of children to be ignored
- Analysis: Czech amendment to education decree opens room for more segregation of schoolchildren
- Czech President's erroneous remarks about school inclusion criticized by experts
- Czech educational attainment influenced by social origins, according to experts
- ROMEA's scholarship recipients encouraged to motivate those around them