Karel Holomek: Inclusive education nowhere in sight in the Czech Republic
The beginning of this school year has taken place with the enrollment of the largest number of first-graders in 20 years, as many as 115 000 children starting instruction. Unfortunately, this favorable development will not continue, according to the prognoses of experts on education.
A new element in this development of the number of children in the schools has also appeared, one that could foreshadow certain difficulties, to say nothing of indicating that the development of education and training in the Czech schools is just groping in the dark. I have in mind the inclusive education of children with special educational needs into mainstream education.
To be clear: This is the professional way of expressing the age-old fact that Romani children have been excluded from mainstream education, and it means nothing less than that these children have been excluded into segregated schools which, while they are nominally primary schools, decidedly are not mainstream. Those who claim otherwise don't know what they're talking about.
The new element is that a larger number of Romani children has turned up in the first-grade classes of the primary schools. This is due to badly-drafted legislation in the housing area and the unfortunate efforts of our municipalities, who are to blame for creating excluded localities - ghettos.
All of the Romani children in town are now being streamed into a single school in their catchment area. There they meet non-Romani pupils.
Many non-Romani parents have been disgusted by this fact. They have immediately enrolled their children in other schools.
On top of it all, the headlines are discussing this - not just in the Czech media, but throughout Europe: "Fleeing Romani pupils in the Czech schools", read one. Shame on them!
This is big. It shows there is something rather unhealthy going on in the Czech state.
That headline will forever be a black mark in the annals of the Czech school system for the year 2014. Moreover, these developments will only continue in the years to come.
Unlike ethnic Czech children (and it is not my intention to draw distinctions, but this is the only way to discuss this indisputable fact), there will continue to be more and more Romani children in the Czech schools in the future - there is probably nothing anyone can do about that. It would be good to realize this fact of demographic development and try to work with it.
Such a trend does not have to indicate a disaster, as many people today believe, but on the contrary indicates a change for the better, an enhancement. Teachers themselves are admitting that the reason non-Romani pupils are fleeing when Romani ones enroll is not the danger that the quality of instruction will deteriorate, but racism pure and simple - I could be more tolerant here and call this just a lack of tolerance caused by non-Romani parents' efforts to get their children into the best school in the first place, and a school with Romani pupils does not strike them as such a school.
We shouldn't have to emphasize that the presence of Romani children can be useful for non-Romani children because Romani children can provide their non-Romani peers with more awareness of a social nature, while Romani children can acquire from their non-Romani schoolmates the notion of setting the rules of a game and their own behavior, and ultimately may experience friendly attitudes from non-Romani people, something they still strongly miss. Imagine what a miracle it will be once such children who have been educated together enter society as adult individuals.
Understandably this will not be an easy, painless process. However, we aren't there yet, and under the current bad circumstances, we will not be there for some time.
We cannot presume that non-Romani parents will abandon their way of thinking and that, with difficulty, they will reconcile themselves to the unavoidable development of the presence of diverse children in the schools. The decision of parents to enroll their children into the school they have chosen for them is holy and inviolable.
What lies before us, to put it mildly, is a grim future of attempting to include Romani children in mainstream education, even with the intensive efforts of many NGOs to enforce such inclusion and to seek it out in practice. This development could take years, if it ever is pushed through at all, because we have a strong lobby against it as well as prejudice and stupidity on all sides.
What to do? As always, comprehensive solutions present themselves, not distinct, separate measures which will fail because they are isolated and not connected to one another.
For the time being no one has made much mention of these solutions in our country. The Czech schools are basically founded on the principal of exclusivity and selectivity and make it possible for children from families motivated to educate themselves (or who are sufficiently wealthy) to choose a selective school to attend.
This is a recipe for inequality, which degrades a democratic society and eventually will destroy it. All parents, after all, want their children to make it to college whether they have what it takes or not.
Currently, after completing the first half of their primary education, children here take entrance tests for academic high school and are tracked based on those results. In this way a primary school loses its "drivers", its best students.
This is the wrong approach. The same primary school education should be attended by all until both halves of it have been completed, and the work with gifted pupils, just like the work with those who fall behind, must completely change.
It's not hard to imagine what kind of behavioral miracles we could expect to see in children coming from wealthy backgrounds in such a system. In our current system these people are growing up as arrogant freaks.
It was somewhere in the education system that the rise of opinions despising poverty or people from "inferior" environments, which all children here identify as Romani, first began. Such opinions and perspectives are usually supported in ethnic Czech families and can be heard rather often in the barbershops and in the pubs.
This worldview is like a plague. Children, of course, only express what they hear at home.
The number of academic high schools in this country should be kept low, reserved only for pupils about whose capabilities there is no doubt. There should be more high-quality vocational schools that offer high school diplomas as well.
In the countries where the greatest successes in children's education have been recorded, those are the governing principles and everything is subordinated to them - the organization of education, the needs of personnel, and indeed, the flow of money. Is this what awaits the Czech Republic in the future?
No chance. We could have done this 10 years ago if our heads had been in the right place!
First published on Karel Holomek's blog.
- Karel Holomek: The fundamental problem remaining for social inclusion in the Czech Republic
- Karel Holomek: When remembrance is out of joint
- Karel Holomek: "Positive discrimination" - nonsense or a total misunderstanding?
- Commentary by Karel Holomek: A killing or a murder?
- Karel Holomek: I have known Václav Havel a long time
- Karel Holomek: Solutions never implemented, ethnic relations will deteriorate
- Commentary by Karel Holomek: The embarrassing end to the Czech presidency of the Decade
- Karel Holomek resigns from Czech Government Inter-ministerial Commission for Roma Community Affairs
- Commentary by Karel Holomek: Czech mayors' declaration is amateurish nonsense!
- Commentary by Karel Holomek: Czech Government social strategy unmasked
- Commentary by Karel Holomek: It's all up to the mayor of Nový Bydžov
- In Brussels, Czech PM indirectly supports Sarkozy, Holomek says he is ignorant
- Czech Decade Ambassador Holomek: Impotent democracies and the Roma
- Holomek may resign as Czech Decade Ambassador over Joch’s appointment
- Decade Ambassador Holomek criticizes Czech PM at Roma Holocaust memorial
- Czech Republic starts its Decade presidency, Karel Holomek is ambassador
- Karel Holomek on the Roma Holocaust, education of the Roma, and the Workers’ Party
- LIVE ONLINE BROADCAST 13:00 CET: Ceremonial awarding of certificates for ROMEA's scholarship program
- Magdalena Karvayová on estimating the distribution of Roma in the schools: Data are important to desegregation
- Central European University offers Master's degree preparatory course for Romani college students
- Romani college prep student in Czech Republic and ROMEA scholarship recipient hopes to become a dentist someday
- Czech Republic sees 10th BARUVAS meeting of Romani students, study abroad one of the topics
- Educator Martin Kaleja: From the Romani settlements in Slovakia to the Czech academic world
- Magdalena Karvayová: Parents in the ghettos need to see education offers their children a future
- Czech research finds that majority must change its approach to Romani people in order to improve the situation in the schools
- European Roma Institute for Arts and Culture offering year-long paid internship in Berlin, Germany
- High schoolers in the Czech capital don't discuss minorities, poll finds they distrust media and politicians
- Young teacher describes how antigypsyism is alive and well in Czech primary education
- Czech Republic sees eighth BARUVAS program meeting for Romani students