Regional Roma association opposes housing benefit-free zones in yet another Czech city
The daily Liberecký deník reported on 26 February that the Czech city of Liberec has increased the number of housing benefit-free zones on municipal territory. Since January that designation has applied to the building at Vojanova Street 138, but it has now been expanded to other properties belonging to the same owner on that same street and to a residential hotel in the Vesec quarter.
"By announcing these zones, we aim to eliminate the intensive disputes taking place among neighbors and understandably also to eliminate the trafficking in poverty that the inhabitants of those buildings have long been at the center of," explained Vice-Mayor of Liberec Ivan Langr, who is behind the local ordinance. The Association of Romani Representatives of the Liberec Region disagrees with the city's decision.
"The housing benefit-free zone will not contribute to increased security, nor will it halt the influx of those relocating inside the city - it is a consequence of the escalation of problems that the city has long ignored," said Association president Iveta Bílková. According to her, the measure could also impact residents who have ended up below the poverty line through no fault of their own.
"It may come to pass that we become witnesses to across-the-board declarations [of such zones] that will have a crippling impact on single mothers, senior citizens and people living with disabilities," Bílková fears. The city, however, is defending itself against such accusations.
Local officials assert that they have done their best, in advance, to find solutions for those socially vulnerable people who are not indebted to extricate themselves from the trafficking-in-poverty trap. "We aided some inhabitants with finding housing, others have taken care of their own situations," Langr explained.
"Currently there's just one family living in that building whom we will apparently be accommodating through the Housing First program, which is social housing for those most in need," said the Vice-Mayor, who believes any other housing would be a significant improvement for the tenants on Vojanova Street. Of course, Langr also admits the matter is not an absolutely simple one.
People must meet the condition of having no debts in order to access rental housing in city-owned apartment units, and the capacity of the rooms in shelter housing may also be a problem when it comes to large families. What's more, not all of the inhabitants of these troubled properties are considered "worth helping" by the city.
Combating the poor
Bílková discussed what it would mean if the city were to declare its entire territory a housing benefit-free zone. In practice this would mean that all renters newly taking up residence in Liberec to whom the owners of private properties might want to rent would no longer have any chance of being considered eligible for state housing benefits.
That would also affect people relocating within the city or municipality, as is the case in Kladno, which has introduced such a zone for the entire town. The owners of buildings and residential hotels who are the traffickers in poverty would no longer cash in on tenants' housing benefits, i.e., on money from the state.
Despite such renters being the poorest people in the Czech Republic, they would have to pay all of their rent from their own resources, which means those unable to find jobs would use their welfare benefits - intended for basic necessities such as food - to cover their housing costs, and therefore would not have enough money left to live on. Many of these people would therefore be forced to borrow money from local loan sharks or usurious firms (as nobody else will loan to them).
People who become indebted in this way no longer have any chance of ever exiting the debt trap during their lifetimes. Most such people are pensioners, single-parent families, or tenants in ghettos.
The vast majority of cities and municipalities in the Czech Republic no longer own social apartment units for which such people could pay a controlled rent, nor do they have the money to build such housing. What's more, local authorities do not want to rent any housing to families who are indebted.
The state itself also does not want to take care of arranging social housing for such people. As representatives of the governing ANO party, led by Czech PM Andrej Babiš, have recently communicated, the Government is not interested in adopting a law on social housing.
Jablonec decided against housing benefit-free zones
The town of Jablonec is betting that reaching agreement with the owners of problematic properties is a better way to proceed. The town is monitoring roughly 20 buildings inhabited by people who have accumulated multiple social problems over time.
At one point Jablonec considered declaring four of the properties as housing benefit-free zones. The town council eventually backed away from that intention, however.
In their view such a move would not address the entire issue. "Those measures do not affect the existing tenants, just the newly-arriving ones," argues Vice-Mayor of Jablonec David Mánek.
Mayor Milan Kroupa began negotiations with the owners of properties about which other people in the neighborhood were complaining. "The situation calmed down there quite quickly after that," the mayor said.
Of course, Kroupa makes no secret of the fact that this approach is a temporary solution. In his view, a better solution would be to buy out the problematic properties and to demolish those in the worst state of repair, ones that are far from meeting public health standards but are frequently ignored by public health authorities, to the surprise of the local administration.
The town would then build new apartments and clearly define the conditions for renting them. Jablonec does not have the money for such an effort, however.
National Agency is against such zones
The Czech Government Agency for Social Inclusion considers the introduction of housing benefit-free zones to be a dead end, as it means local authorities will no longer be able to respond on a case-by-case basis to the specific situations of families or individuals. "Such steps can, in reality, do harm to the groups who are most in danger, such as the parents of minor children, single mothers, senior citizens, and people living with disabilities. Domestic violence victims are also faced with an additional problem - if they decide to emancipate themselves, then during the first phase of their 'new life' they are usually dependent exactly on these benefits," Agency director David Beňák said previously.
- Czech Government Agency for Social Inclusion criticizes housing benefit-free zones
- Yet another Czech city announces its entire territory to be a housing benefit-free zone
- Czech Govt will not draft social housing law or anti-poverty measures
- Czech Govt Agency for Social Inclusion does not support housing benefit-free zones in Liberec
- Yet another Czech town bans housing benefits, opposition politician and Romani NGO object
- Czech Republic: 88 cities in 12 regions plan to ban housing benefits in specific zones
- Nonprofits and unions call on Czech PM to put forward social housing law
- Robin Stria, 7th place candidate for the Greens, Brno-střed: The biggest problem in the Czech Republic is housing
- Analysis finds collections increasing in Czech Republic, affordable housing lacking
- Czech Public Defender of Rights calls for social housing law, says media should stop blaming Roma
- Czech research shows 96 % of poorest families in Rapid Re-Housing maintain their housing and improve their health
- Civil society members of Czech Govt Roma Council leave meeting in protest against housing benefit-free zones
- Czech Green Party says current housing crisis involving Romani evictees makes previous ones seem humane by comparison
- Experts from around the globe speak in Czech capital about affordable housing
- Czech Social Democrats would withdraw controversial plan to further restrict housing benefits
- Czech village wants to stop housing benefits altogether, plans to buy up apartment buildings
- Czech elections once again fail to elect a Romani legislator to the lower house
- Alternative for Germany, the anti-immigration populists, arguing internally over whether 10 % of the vote is success
- Czech Spolu (Together) coalition: Education is the path to better integration of Roma, "inadaptables" don't want to conform
- Six Romani men and women are running in Czech elections to the lower house, one for ANO and Levice, two for the Greens, two for ultranationalist party
- Czech town sees 6 000 people attend Romfest in runup to elections, Romani figures explained the importance of voting and warned against ultranationalists
- Zeljko Jovanovic: Low COVID-19 immunization rate among the European Roma is the result of decades of government neglect
- Fire in Czech town destroys building where bereaved relatives of Stanislav Tomáš, the Romani man who died in police custody in June, were living
- Romanian town must finally compensate some members of a forcibly evicted Romani community
- Vojtěch Lavička: Czech law on housing benefit-free zones was an attack on human dignity
- Czech nonprofits welcome abolition of local "housing benefit-free zones", say they made matters worse
- Czech mobile vaccination teams revisit socially excluded localities where COVID-19 disinformation has had more of an impact
- Jaroslav Miko: Czech President shows his arrogance and lack of basic social empathy on the first day of school