Romani evictees seek compensation from town, Czech Supreme Court to review case
The case of the Romani residents of Vsetín who were removed from its territory and relocated to villages outside of the Zlín Region nine years ago will be addressed by the Czech Supreme Court. The Romani plaintiffs believe the town violated their fundamental human rights by removing them.
Their lawsuit has been ruled on three times by the Ostrava Regional Court, which has repeatedly thrown it out. Those lower court verdicts have always been overturned by the High Court in Olomouc.
According to former Mayor and current Senator Jiří Čunek (Christian Democrats - KDU-ČSL), the town of Vsetín appealed that High Court decision to the Supreme Court last month, which will begin reviewing the case in a few months. The Romani residents claim they were forcibly "deported" from Vsetín.
They are also criticizing the fact that they were forced by employees of the local authority to sign papers they never even had the opportunity to read relating to the purchase by them of real estate and that they were unable to freely choose the place to which they would move with their families. The properties where they ended up were absolutely unfit for human habitation.
The Romani residents are seeking compensation of CZK 5.2 million from the town. According to Čunek, however, these were families who were not paying their rent and whose eviction was court-ordered, and the town would have been within its rights to simply turn them out onto the street.
"We aided them, and now we're supposed to pay them damages. I am concerned that on the basis of this absurd, unjust trial, the town of Vsetín will not extend the leases of the Romani families who were involved in the removals back then and the only address I'll be able to recommend to them for addressing their housing is the High Court in Olomouc," Čunek said.
A case for the Public Defender of Rights
Vsetín evicted the Roma from a dilapidated apartment building in the town center in 2006. The town hall bought old houses in the Jeseniky and Prostějov districts (in an entirely different region), moved the evicted tenants into them, and is now requiring them to pay the town back for the real estate over the next 20 years.
A total of 40 Romani families were removed by the town to its periphery and housed in apartment units made out of metal containers. Some of them were moved by the town hall into the dilapidated houses in the villages in the Jeseniky and Prostějov districts.
Three families who were not paying rent were removed into old houses in the villages of Stará Červená Voda, Vidnava and Vlčice. The Romani people living in those houses are paying them off as interest-free loans.
Čunek later moved other Romani tenants out of Vsetín, this time into the Prostějov district, into the villages of Čechy pod Kosířem a Dřevnovice. These were two separate families with a total of 26 members.
This case of eviction has been reviewed by almost 10 police, the state attorney, and then-Public Defender of Rights Otakar Motejl. While according to the police officers Čunek did not break the law by evicting the tenants, Motejl said the town hall did make an error and violated the Romani tenants' rights to respect for their family and private life, and the Human Rights Committee of the Czech Senate subsequently supported his stance on the incident.
Kids will go to a home
Ms Jolana Tulejová expressed her views in 2006 to iDNES.cz of the way the entire removal occurred, as did other evictees. "They scared us by saying we would end up on the street and kids would go to a home," she said.
Other Romani evictees claim Čunek gave them an unequivocal choice: Either they would end up on the street and lose their welfare, or they would be provided a loan with which to buy a single-family home somewhere. The usual practice for acquiring the properties included a broker masquerading as a prospective cottager who visited the single-family homes ultimately intended for the Roma who pretended to be interested in buying them.
"If I had known he was just going to resell it, I would never have signed the contract. It's an old, small building that needs repairs. Eleven people can't even fit in it," Olga Juklová, one of the original owners of the properties at issue, told the Czech daily Mf DNES at the time.
She sold her single-family home through the Prostějov-based office Real Spektrum for CZK 320 000. The Tulej couple is now paying CZK 460 000 for it.
A clean town
- Commentary: In Czech Republic, Romani evictees reunite in their old neighborhood
- Czech NGO wants to buy buildings from which Romani tenants were evicted
- Czech Republic: Activists, evictees to hold open meeting on housing in Ostrava
- Czech municipality claims it offered evictees leases, they say otherwise
- Czech landlord leases property on Monday, evicts tenants on Friday
- Czech NGO: Information on next wave of evictions in Ústí being suppressed
- Nine families still at risk of eviction and homelessness in Ostrava
- Czech Republic: Gentrification evicts more poor in Ostrava
- Czech initiative finds housing for Romani residential hotel evictees
- Czech initiative says town must take responsibility for evictees
- Czech NGO: Some evicted families rejected housing options without giving a reason
- Czech firm to evict residential hotel tenants tonight
- Czech nonprofits: Some evicted families have been housed in Ústí
- On-line reporting of demonstration against evictions
- Czech Police arrest 12 after demo against evictions
- "Housing for All" to protest evictions at Czech Labor Ministry
- Czech Agency says evicted tenants must be housed in the same town
- AI: Romani families face forced eviction while Czech town earmarks EU funds for social inclusion
- Czech town requests bailiffs evict Romani tenants
- Czech Republic: Romani tenant says evictions would further property sale
- Amnesty International contacts Czech mayor over ghetto evictions
- Romani family evicted by Čunek in 2006 loses home again
- Czech town buys building in order to evict Romani tenants
- Roma residents of "container" housing face eviction in the Czech Republic
- Czech Government report finds evictions of Roma from Vsetín costly and counterproductive
- Czech town evicts two Romany families over debts
- Czech Vsetin evicts Romany family over repeated disturbance
- SLUM-LIKE CONDITIONS FOR EVICTED ROMA FAMILIES
- No help to be provided to evicted Czech Romanies-press
- Eviction of Romanies in Vsetin was mistake - Czech Ombudsman
- Romanies moved from Vsetin do not pay loans, may be evicted again
- Another eviction of Czech Romanies ahead - press
- Czech Romany activist insists on illegality of eviction
- High Court fight to evict Gypsies
- Evicted Romany families should get money - Czech minister
- Czech Interior Ministry plan to house Romani refugees from Ukraine scuppered by Regional Governors, four bids sought from private sector instead
- Czech detention facility housing 130+ refugees from Ukraine, half of them are Romani
- Prague asks the Czech state for aid with accommodation of groups of Romani refugees from Ukraine, mayor says the state's effort has failed so far
- Czech reporter: "Why are Romani refugees ending up in detention facilities? Because nobody else wants them!"
- Czech Regional Governors reject most buildings proposed for housing Romani refugees from Ukraine, agreeing on just three with the Interior Minister
- Roma Luma leaders: Romani refugees from Ukraine are discriminated in the Czech Republic. Regional Governors and ombudsman: These are economic migrants
- Czech state acknowledges problem with finding accommodation for Romani Ukrainian refugees, Mayor of Prague calls for all free capacities to be provided
- Civil society members of Czech Govt Roma Council call on Romani men and women to aid Romani Ukrainian refugees with finding housing by using state program
- Czech Labor and Social Affairs Minister gets a haircut at a Romani-owned barbershop to mark World Roma Day
- Michal Mižigár: What myths exist about World Roma Day and what is the reality?
- More than 3 000 people assembled to celebrate World Roma Day in Ostrava, Czech Republic - footage of performances here
- Romani refugees segregated in a Czech center and discriminated against, Regional Governor accuses them of theft, police say no such crimes have been reported