Canada removes plaque from its first National Holocaust Monument after backlash
The Guardian reports that Canada’s first National Holocaust Monument in Ottawa was opened on September 27th. Designed by a team led by Gail Dexter Lord, the son of Holocaust survivors, the monument takes the shape of the yellow star that Jews were forced to wear in Nazi Germany and the territories under Nazi occupation.
Despite the specifically Jewish reference of the monument’s design and panels referencing Jewish people as resisting the Nazis, being targets for mass murder, and suffering from Canada’s discriminatory wartime immigration policy, a small plaque unveiled at the opening referred just to “the millions of men, women and children murdered during the Holocaust” and did not specifically reference the ethnicity, nationality or religion of any of the victims. That plaque has now been removed after conservative opposition lawmakers complained, the Guardian reports.
One of the public figures to call for the removal of the plaque was Canadian Member of Parliament (MP) David Sweet. His Ottawa staff say that he condemned the plaque for failing to explicitly mention Jews and the fight against antisemitism after being contacted by some Jewish members of his constituency.
“If we are going to stamp out hatred toward Jews, it is important to get history right,” Sweet was quoted as saying by the Guardian on October 3rd. This is not the first time he has become involved with Holocaust survivors and issues of their representation.
According to his office staff, Sweet has also assisted the Canadian Roma who have been advocating for a day of National Remembrance on August 2nd for Roma Holocaust victims. That motion was not passed this time around.
Generally speaking, Holocaust remembrance worldwide currently focuses on the numbers of different victims documented to date. The U.S. Holocaust Memorial Museum web page, for example, begins with the information that “The Holocaust was the systematic, bureaucratic, state-sponsored persecution and murder of six million Jews by the Nazi regime and its collaborators”.
Canada’s Heritage Minister, Mélanie Joly, is quoted by the Guardian as saying that the recently-unveiled monument in her country was attempting to also acknowledge the “five million other [non-Jewish] victims murdered during the Holocaust.” Indeed, the U.S. Holocaust Memorial Museum also mentions that those who fell victim to the Holocaust included “Roma (Gypsies), the disabled, and some of the Slavic peoples (Poles, Russians, and others). Other groups were persecuted on political, ideological, and behavioral grounds, among them Communists, Socialists, Jehovah's Witnesses, and homosexuals.”
In Canada, what should have been an occasion to remember the victims and survivors of the Holocaust has instead become a controversy. Joly has said the plaque will be replaced with “language that reflects the horrors experienced by the Jewish people”.
Antisemitism, Holocaust denial and historical revisionism persist worldwide today. Some democracies are trying to strike the balance between acknowledging the central role that antisemitism played in the Nazis’ atrocities against Jewish people and also acknowledging that many who were not Jewish were targeted by the Nazis for murder on the grounds of other specifically-stigmatized characteristics.
It is also worth noting that while in terms of documented numbers the Romani victims of the Holocaust are currently estimated as fewer than the Jewish victims, when it comes to the proportion of their communities who were murdered, the Holocaust was, sadly, extraordinarily efficient in the Roma case, especially in the Protectorate of Bohemia and Moravia. It is currently estimated that as much as 90 % of the interwar Romani population of that geographic area fell victim to the Holocaust.
Today’s international Romani community has been seeking explicit mention of their Holocaust suffering during some international and national commemorations. The 2016 commemoration at the United Nations included Mr. Zoni Weisz, a Sinto survivor, while Roma musicians Antal Kopar and Bela Horvath performed, but no specifically Romani community members are mentioned as having been involved in this year's ceremony.
In Europe there are currently some examples of Jewish and Romani communities joining forces when it comes to Holocaust remembrance and combating present-day racism. With support from the EVZ Foundation, a nonprofit group in Hungary called UCCU, the Roma Informal Education Foundation, sends a joint team of Jewish and Romani community members into high schools to discuss these issues - for many youth it is the first time any of them have ever met an actual Jewish or Romani person.
- Czech Republic: "Stumbling-stones" commemorate Romani Holocaust victims for the first time ever
- Commentary: By honoring Zeman, US Jewish organization is promoting the fascisization of Czech society
- Czech Culture Minister's statement on Roma Holocaust Memorial Day
- International Roma flag to fly on buildings throughout Czech Republic tomorrow for Roma Holocaust Remembrance Day
- Emílie Machálková, a Czech Romani Holocaust survivor, has passed away
- Convicted German neo-Nazi who is a former Red Army Faction terrorist arrested in Hungary after seeking asylum
- Romania: Ethnic Hungarian mob commits arson against Romani children accused of stealing
- European Commission disturbed by Hungary's CEU moves, could sue for violating EU law and values
- American and Canadian embassies in Prague display Romani flag for International Romani Day
- Hungarian PM attacks nonprofits supported by Soros, wants to close them
- Canada: Czechoslovak Roma express support for Romani celebrity and condemn Czech support for xenophobic band
- Hungarian teachers take to the streets seeking integration of Roma and apology from PM
- Roma Holocaust Memorial Day marks the Nazi murder of Roma and Sinti at Auschwitz on 2-3 August 1944
- Romania: 900 protest recent violence against Roma in Italy and Ukraine, more demonstrations in other European countries to follow
- OSCE Mission to Serbia responds to Romani NGOs about alleged radicalization, references British Council report
- Romani NGOs around Europe ask why the OSCE is researching alleged radicalization of their communities in Serbia
- Belgium: Roma Travellers evicted from caravan site in Anderlecht neighborhood of Brussels
- Belgium: Roma Travellers to be evicted in EU capital, fire reported at their halting site
- Week-long education event at Terezín also honors genocide of Roma with concert and flag
- Albania: Romani people left without citizenship anywhere
- Jonathan Lee: Antigypsyism is a cancer at the heart of Europe
- Nationalists desecrate Czech memorial to genocide of the Roma
- Renata Berkyová: Concept of the Porajmos as a reflection of the marginalization of Roma in historiography
- RESPEKT: Czech EdMin considering amendments that could undo inclusive education
Tags:antigypsyism, antisemitism, Canada, Civil society, genocide, History, Holocaust
Tomáš Ščuka: Romani people need competent representation first and foremost, not Romani representation at all costs1.8.2018 10:04
Každý diskutující musí dodržovat PRAVIDLA DISKUZE SERVERU Romea.cz. Moderátoři serveru Romea.cz si vyhrazují právo bez předchozího upozornění skrýt nevhodné příspěvky z diskuse na Romea.cz. Ty pak budou viditelné jen pro vás a vaše přátele na Facebooku. Při opakovaném porušení pravidel mohou moderátoři zablokovat zobrazování vašich příspěvků v diskusích na Romea.cz ostatním uživatelům.