Commentary by Czech MEP Zdechovský: Roma need work, not welfare!
The integration of Romani people into society is not succeeding very well. It has been attempted for better or for worse and a great deal of money has been poured into different virtuous projects.
What has been the result? Most of the time, nothing.
The integration of Romani people into society is not much succeeding in the Czech Republic, Slovakia, or other European countries. Countless solutions have already been tried.
The situation of Romani people, unfortunately, has not made one inch of progress. It is not surprising, therefore, that frustration is growing among the majority population and the Roma themselves along with the number of unsuccessful projects.
The miracle in Spišský Hrhov
A solution does exist for each problem, however, and the problems of the Romani minority are no exception. Experience with an integration project for Romani people in the Slovak village of Spišský Hrhov is proof that sometimes all it takes is for people to begin using their brains.
In this village in eastern Slovakia, one-fifth of the 1 800 local inhabitants are Romani, and integration there has been so successful that the village has received a great deal of appreciation and attention far beyond the borders of Slovakia, thanks to the current Mayor Vladimír Ledecký. Germany's ARD television channel has broadcast a report about the place, and two years ago the leading American newspaper The New York Times dedicated an article to it as well.
The beginnings for the current mayor were not at all easy, however. When he took office in 1998, the community was similar to many others in eastern Slovakia with large Romani communities.
The village at the time had just 700 inhabitants, half of whom were Romani, and the non-Romani population was dying out. The Romani residents lived in shacks without electricity, almost all of them were unemployed, and one-fifth of their children attended special needs schools.
What is the current situation there like? Unemployment among the Roma has fallen to 20 %, which can be considered an enormous success.
Romani children there are attending normal schools and three of them have gone on to college, according to the New York Times. Naturally, the level of housing in the village has improved.
The formerly illegally-built Romani shacks have now been transformed into brick buildings and housing units that are legal and the Romani residents have either bought or leased them. People from the surrounding area have begun to move into the village in large numbers thanks to its brilliant reputation and low real estate prices.
The number of inhabitants has more than doubled. Interest in real estate there has also been expressed by people living abroad.
Somebody from London has bought a vacation villa there, and a family from the Netherlands has also moved there. The main thing is that relationships among the Roma and everybody else are currently absolutely seamless.
The easy, genius solution of the local mayor
We can doubtless consider Spišský Hrhov a "success story" - and what was the secret to this success? The mayor came up with a single solution that was very easy, and yet it was genius.
He employed local Romani residents in the municipality's construction company, which he himself established to contribute to construction projects for local housing and infrastructure. After a while, the results were in.
The Romani residents had accepted the helping hand he offered them and had begun working. Through their labor they have beautified the entire community and managed to better integrate into society.
In addition, prejudices against Romani people have fallen by the wayside there. This is plain to see, right?
This lesson leads to a single conclusion: Romani people do not need social welfare. They need to be employed and to acquire the habit of work above all.
The problems of Romani communities will never be solved by inventing "x" number of ways to constantly stuff them with money and welfare. They must mainly begin living in standard housing and working.
Romani people will also begin to behave better once that happens. In Britain, Romani people have housing and jobs and are succeeding well there - just like in Spišský Hrhov.
Just one question occurs to me: Why are people unable to draw more inspiration from the places where integration works? I wish you all a good day and happy minds!
Originally reprinted from the author's blog on iDNES.cz with his permission.
- International Network against Cyber Hate and ROMEA hold conference on antigypsyism and online hate in Czech capital
- Czech court says police officer who beat Romani worker did not commit a felony
- International work experience opens up for unemployed youth in the Czech Republic
- EU citizens in the UK - many of them Roma - requesting "settled status" so they can live and work there after Brexit
- EU anti-fraud authority Hungarian program for Roma supported by EU funds has never worked and should be investigated
- Czech Agriculture Ministry advises hiring Ukrainian labor despite domestic Romani labor offer for bark beetle work
- Czech candidate for party that used racist slogan now works for new group aiding Roma
- Czech lower house rejects Senate amendments to bankruptcy bill, passes version unlikely to satisfy those who work with debtors
- Czech Labor and Social Affairs Ministry plans revision of welfare within several months
- Czech Govt rejects SocDem proposal to increase welfare system baseline
- Slovak ironworks prefers to hire Romani citizens instead of foreign nationals
- Czech Civic Democrats want to suspend welfare for misdemeanor recidivists
- ROMEA: Czech President has manipulated facts yet again - we can prove 70 % of Romani people in this country work
- European Roma flood Facebook with hundreds of photos of themselves at work, tell Czech President to stop insulting them
- Czech President alleges Romani people "do not want to work" and that "slapping them" is the best way to deal with them
- Czech Agriculture Ministry wants to collaborate with Romani business group, says Czech Forests already working with one
- Czech MEP Zdechovský for ROMEA TV: Romani projects must have concrete outputs like the Romani scholarships do
- Czech institute reminds President that welfare restrictions have applied for more than a decade now
- Czech expert says child welfare authorities should address discrimination in the schools
- Czech Republic: Welfare recipients to be banned from playing slot machines
- Czech survey shows welfare less acceptable than murder or stealing
- Czech Republic: Facts and myths about Romani people and welfare
- Czech PM: "The state will not help delinquents and slackers who abuse welfare"
- Czech Republic: Photograph of "welfare" receipt circulating online is yet another fraud
- Czech Senate rejects bill on subjecting welfare to collections
- President of Slovakia Zuzana Čaputová posts in Romanes for Roma Holocaust Memorial Day: Te e historija na avel pale kampel te achaľol, so hin ňenavisť
- British authorities sentence couple who enslaved Romani youth to nine and 16 years in prison respectively
- Belgian city relocates immigrant Romani families from slums to residential sites on its outskirts
- Slovak President Zuzana Čaputová met with Roma students on the occasion of World Roma Day
- Czech Govt raises minimum levels of income baselines for benefit calculations this month by 10 %, still less than actual inflation
- Slovak Govt Plenipotentiary for Romani Communities joins aid effort for refugees from Ukraine, monitoring patrols will make sure Romani refugees are assisted too
- Slovak firefighter tells ROMEA TV his remarks about Roma from Ukraine were based on what they themselves told him and the Czech reporter misunderstood him
- Slovak Interior Minister refuses to comment on firefighter's racist remarks about Romani refugees from Ukraine
- Commentary: Stop idealizing poverty
- Excluded Roma in Slovakia have died of COVID-19 more than non-Roma due to low rates of vaccination, their employment rates have also stagnated
- Czech Republic, Hungary, Slovakia: NGO reports that LGBT+ Roma face discrimination from their own families as well as majority societies in these EU Member States
- Slovak Govt Plenipotentiary for Romani Communities Ján Hero: Census numbers do not reflect the actual number of Romani men and women here