Human Rights Watch says Czech debate on migration would cause an uproar if understood in the West
According to Andrew Stroehlein of the Brussels branch of Human Rights Watch (HRW), the domestic public debate about the refugee crisis is being led in the Czech Republic in a way that would cause an international uproar if it were happening in a Western European country. The reputation of the Czech Republic and its politicians, he believes, is protected to a significant degree by the fact that few people outside the country speak Czech.
"If some of the things that have been said recently in the Czech debate were instead said in France or Germany, for example, the international community would be in disarray over them - not just because it would show a very different atmosphere in that society, but because the outside world would immediately take notice," Stroehlein believes. He went on to say that the Czech Republic, Hungary and Slovakia, three of the four Visegrad group countries (the V4) are living in a "comfortable, isolated bubble".
It is precisely the V4 countries that are currently the loudest opponents of the European Commission's proposals to redistribute some of the asylum-seekers currently in Greece, Hungary and Italy among other EU-28 states. Discussions in the V4 of EU quotas for refugee redistribution and the more general debates about the current wave of migrants and refugees, comprised of people from Syria and other countries in the Middle East and Africa, are frequently permeated with anti-Muslim and xenophobic sentiment.
This is not just a matter of online discussions. Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orbán, during his visit to Brussels last week, defended to journalists what he called the right of Hungarians to demand that large groups of Muslims not live in their country by referring to "historical experience".
In the Czech Republic, Stroehlein notes that the most vocal group on this issue is called "We Don't Want Islam in the Czech Republic", which is led by biologist Martin Konvička. "It is interesting that the most extreme, strongest anti-Muslim rhetoric is coming from a country that has absolutely no experience with them (with Muslims)," the HRW representative said.
However, he believes it is far more serious that such a group has also been supported in interviews given to the media by Czech President Miloš Zeman. "This is bizarre. I think that if something like this were to happen in an EU Member State whose language is understood by more people, the situation would be completely different," Stroehlein said.
Journalist Jan Čulík has already translated some of the controversial remarks made by Czech activists and politicians and published them online. "Once this gets out of the Czech bubble and someone translates a couple of these articles and quotations, others will be amazed. This is slowly happening. There is a need to get some fresh air into this closed debate," Stroehlein noted.
This is not, of course, the first time that Czech politicians have done their best to exploit and play on citizens' concerns and fears. Stroehlein says that Miroslav Sládek, for example, behaved this way in the Czech Republic in the 1990s but always remained a fringe figure on the political scene.
"This is not new. However, I think it's stronger now and more mainstream than ever before. That prompts concern," the HRW representative said.
- Czech presidential candidates Dienstbier, Fischer, and Zeman debate human rights
- Czech Romani activist debates central misdemeanor registry, prosecution of Tanvald shooting
- Czech human rights community debates ethnic identification of felony perpetrators
- Commentary: Romani representatives lost the Czech Television debate
- International experts debate how to link Holocaust archives
- Online debater convicted in Czech Republic of death threats against Roma moderator
- ROMEA representatives debate the image of Roma people in the Czech media
- Human Rights Watch criticizes EU and USA for not doing enough on human rights
- European Parliament to debate Roma expulsions
- Roma housing debate
- Czechs should open EU debate on Romany problems - minister
- Slovak fascist politician claimed COVID-19 didn't exist. Now he has it.
- Ten years on from neo-Nazi arson conviction, Czech attorney warns it could happen again
- Czech riot police intervene against violent anti-COVID measure demonstrators
- Slovak media and NGOs welcome conviction of right-wing extremist
- Slovak politician gets 4 months and 4 years for establishing a movement to suppress human rights, he appeals
- Czech Senate elections won by "Mayors" party, xenophobic rhetoric scored no votes, owner of disinformation tabloid not reseated
- Czech poll finds 30 % of the public does not want Romani children in mainstream classes and does want them to be segregated
- Czech Interior Ministry: Ultranationalist party attempted to spark anti-Romani sentiment, extremists and xenophobes spread disinformation about COVID-19
- Czech court upholds suspended sentence for man who called for non-white first-graders to be gassed to death
- Czech Senate election: Romani candidate says right-wing extremists could take power unless people vote for their competitors
- Council of Europe says Czech Republic not doing enough to teach the Romani language
- Slovak Prosecutor says party head clearly used neo-Nazi symbolism so his followers would know his views