Russia: Massacre of Romani people in the Urals, two dead, six injured, media reporting is biased
A tragic exchange of gunfire in Russia between a group of Romani people and three local non-Romani businessmen on Saturday, 3 September has resulted in the deaths of two Romani people and the injury of six. Some media outlets in Russia are reporting the incident as an assault perpetrated by a group of armed Roma on some unsuspecting local entrepreneurs who had no choice but to defend their own lives and protect their family members.
Gradually, however, the investigation and prosecution of the incident is revealing that the reality of the situation differs from the initial reporting. Oleg Shishov, the local entrepreneur in question who is also a former soldier with combat experience, owns a house adjacent to the Romani quarter in Yekaterinburg in the Urals.
Earlier this week Shishov was accused by a court in Sverdlovsk of having exceeded the limits of reasonable self-defense during the incident. The case has sparked significant public interest.
Many Russian media outlets are depicting Shishov as a hero who is being unfairly investigated by the police and the courts. That depiction is sparking fear in society and feeding anti-Romani hatred.
Insult to honor
The 38-year-old Shishov is an influential entrepreneur in the Urals whose construction firm has won lucrative contracts all over the country. Previously, in connection with a commission to build a gigantic, modern oceanic aquarim in Vladivostok, Shishov spent several weeks in police custody on suspicion of corruption but was ultimately released.
Alexander and Alexei Dutov, two brothers who were visiting the businessman on the day in question, are also former Russian special forces soldiers, like Shishov. During the exchange of gunfire that day, Alexei Dutov was injured in the arm.
According to the reporting so far, Alexander Dutov and Shishov first began firing at the Romani people, then fled the scene and spent two nights and one day hiding in the forest. On the night of Monday, 5 September, they called a press conference and announced they were turning themselves in.
During their press conference they alleged that a group of 30 armed Romani men had driven up to Shishov's house in six cars and attacked without warning. They claimed to have engaged in reasonable self-defense in order to protect Shishov's wife and three children.
On 12 September, some Russian media outlets, such as the Kommersant newspaper, published another description of what happened, one that detectives are pursuing. According to that version, Shishov had insulted a Romani man, Dmitry Pestrikov, who is living with Alexander Dutov's daughter, during a birthday celebration.
Pestrikov demanded an apology, to no avail. One week later, he allegedly visited Shishov together with 15 other men in order to force him to apologize.
An argument broke out on the street in front of Shishov's house. Alexei Dutov and Shisov then began firing at the Roma.
Courts under pressure
Detectives and state oversight officials working on the investigation do not seem to be on the same page about what happened. Shishov at first was remanded into custody after admitting his involvement in the incident to police, but was released several days later through the intercession of a state superintendent who was not assigned to the case.
The Superior Court in Sverdlovsk has received a complaint from the attorney for the Romani victims and new evidence, and has preliminarily decided that Shishov exceeded the limits of reasonable self-defense and that a new criminal prosecution will begin against him. The Russian media have reacted by calling the court's decision scandalous.
A reporter for the state television station NTV was so distraught over what he characterized as the allegedly insufficient right of Russian citizens to defend themselves that he told viewers "This could never happen in America." Other media outlets have not yet commented on whether it is actually acceptable to speak with such admiration about Russia's ideological enemy on state television, but in general the Russian media has a tendency to pressure legislators there to loosen restrictions in the law on reasonable self-defense and in the laws on how to legally obtain weapons.
- Russia: Mass demolition of homes in one of the biggest Romani settlements
- Russia: Romani residents of Tula rebel over gas supplies
- Germany: Neo-Nazis and populists march in Berlin waving fake Third Reich flags and those of Russia
- Czech branch of Russia's "Wotan Jugend" to stand trial
- Commentary: Russian propaganda claims both "Jews" and "Nazis" now rule Ukraine
- Russia: Neo-Nazi gang connected to Kremlin murdered anti-Fascists, immigrants and judges
- Czech President offends brave Russians who stood up for Czechoslovakia in 1968
- UN: Pro-Russian separatists, Ukrainian forces violating human rights
- Russia: Romani scientists were also sisters
- Former Czech President, Communist Party leader attend reception at Russian Embassy
- Czech Police break up cell of Russian neo-Nazi organization
- Russia and Fascism: When the thief cries "Stop thief!"
- Ukraine: Pro-Russian separatists want to "purge" Slavyansk of "Gypsies"
- Pro-Russian radicals target Roma for assault in eastern Ukraine
- Czech poll: Roma least-liked, Russians lose favor
- Czech Supreme Court to review verdict in shooting murder of Romani man in Chomutov
- VIDEO: Museum of Romani Culture Award given to Romani activist David Tišer
- Czech politicians respond to President's antigypsyism: He divides us so we won't unite against him
- Czech capital to see seminar on stereotypes in the photographic depictions of Jewish and Romani people
- Czech Republic: Eva Davidová, an ethnographer who loved Romani people, has passed away
- Czech convicted of racially-motivated murder of Romani man is running for mayor
- Czech appeals court reduces sentence for murder of Romani man to seven years, prosecutor calls it disproportionate, inhumane and unjust
- Martina Horváthová on building a network of Romani feminists in the Czech Republic
- Slovak court convicts Romani victims of police raid for making allegedly false accusations of brutality
- Slovak media have video footage of brutal attack that killed Filipino, suspect is in custody
- Slovakia: Filipino attempts to prevent harassment of women, harasser kicks him to death
- Irena Biháriová: Comprehending the matrix of a Romani settlement in Slovakia is not easy