Slovak church bungles inclusion of Romani newcomer into First Communion ceremony, charges of racial discrimination being investigated
Slovak media and online social networks have recently been discussing the case of a Romani girl who was told that during her First Communion at the Basilica of St. Nicholas in Trnava she would not be allowed to sit with the rest of the children - at their parents' request. The mother of the 11-year-old girl first posted a description of her situation to the "Ask a Lawyer" group on social media the night before the ceremony asking for advice about what to do.
"Would you be able to advise me where to file a complaint ... for discrimination? Tomorrow we are meant, or rather my daughter is meant, to attend her First Communion, and today we went to confession, and the other parents of the other children do not want my daughter to sit in front with the rest of the kids, they want us as a family to be seated in the back. What can I do in such a case?" the post read.
In the discussion beneath her post, the mother later alleged that the church had offered to hold a separate First Communion ceremony just for her daughter. Jozef Viskupič, Governor of the Trnava Region, whose son was meant to attend the same service, subsequently contacted the chaplain and told him he believed it would be unacceptable for one child to have to sit separately from the rest during First Communion.
"He agreed and the girl was able to sit with everybody else. I informed the catechetical leaders and the mass took place in dignity and humility and in God's temple, where we should all be - and all are - equal," the Governor posted to Facebook after the service.
The situation was also condemned in a live social media broadcast by the Governor's cousin and chair of the Ordinary People and Independent Figures movement ((OĽaNO), Igor Matovič. The party chair claimed that the Governor had told the chaplain, among other things, that if he were to succumb to the pressure from the other non-Romani parents, the Governor would hold the Romani girl on his lap during the ceremony.
"In my view this is a catastrophic example of our internal racism - we are even able to demonstrate our racism towards a defenseless child at her First Communion, on such a big day for her," Matovič said. According to some of the non-Romani parents, however, the seating arrangement issue was not about racism.
"We were addressing the seating of the parents, not the children. That's essential, it was never even hinted at that the child would sit somewhere in the back," one of the parents told news server aktuality.sk.
That same parent then sent a more detailed statement by the non-Romani parents to the editors of that news server. The statement describes that the girl at issue had not attended the ceremony rehearsal together with the other children, had not been seen on Friday at confession, and that allegedly nobody had paid for her share of the ceremony, including the gift each child receives.
The non-Romani parents were, therefore, startled to learn the girl would attend the ceremony, as they had not been informed. "We want to clarify that under no circumstances did any of the parents make any remarks about the girl's origins. One Romani girl has already been here among our children, it wasn't a problem, there were no allusions made to her origins, nothing of the sort. That child regularly attended all the activities together with her parents," the non-Romani parents say in their statement, adding that what they disliked was the fact that the girl had not attended the rehearsal and was not, in their view, prepared for the ceremony.
The parish of Trnava responded to the incident, stating that the girl had come to them from a different parish and a different school. Her mother, according to the parish, asked to join the First Holy Communion about a week before the ceremony was to take place.
The parson therefore asked the opinion of the catechistical leaders in the other parish, who had taught the girl for the last two years, whether she was prepared to receive communion. After they confirmed to him that she was, he agreed to accept the girl's participation in the ceremony.
"The seating order was determined not because of discrimination, which we thoroughly reject, but because she applied late and did not attend preparations and rehearsal," the parish said in its statement, adding that spiritual services are annually provided to dozens of believers from the Romani community and no problems have ever arisen during them. The case is currently being investigated by the National Criminal Agency.
- Winner of Czech-Slovak singing competition "The Voice" subjected to racist attacks online
- EP elections: Four Romani candidates in Czech Republic, more than 20 in Slovakia
- Stano Daniel: Czecho-Slovak perspectives on elections to the European Parliament
- Romani candidate has actual chance of becoming an MEP after party chair in Slovakia withdraws and backs him
- Slovak President-elect says a single court decision cannot solve the problem of extremism and Fascism
- Commentary: Czech Republic, Slovakia must compensate the victims of forced sterilization while they are still alive
- How Easter has been celebrated among Roma of Slovak or Vlax origin in the Czech Republic
- Slovak Police investigating hateful, antigypsyist Facebook post
- Slovakia: Romani children from excluded communities sing Romani national anthem at the Presidential Palace
- Slovak football tournament brings together diplomats, Roma and politicians for the fifth time
- Slovakia has elected its first female President - Čaputová thanks voters in Romanes again
- Irena Biháriová: How a Romani woman from Progressive Slovakia got a hug from an ultra-right voter
- Slovakia: Ultra-right tries to exploit tragedy, raise tensions between non-Roma and Roma
- Slovak President Kiska receives the European Civil Rights Prize of Sinti and Roma in Brussels
- Slovak Presidential elections: Frontrunner speaks Romanes when thanking first-round voters
- Romani vocalists from Czech Republic and Slovakia record pop music video duet
- Romani girl who won race in Slovakia while running in flats keeps on winning
- Romani kickbox champ of Czech Republic celebrates victory at Muay-Thai evening in Slovakia with Romani flag around his shoulders
- Bulgarian officials exploiting fear of COVID-19 to discriminate against Roma
- Jan Horvát: Czech and Slovak Govts must immediately combat COVID-19 in excluded localities
- Slovak NGOs demand crisis plan from Govt to prevent COVID-19 pandemic in Romani communities, ombudswoman supports them
- Czech town puts "container housing" for Romani-inhabited locality on hold, former ombudswoman recommended cancelling it altogether
- France: Four Romani community members die of COVID-19, others are in critical condition
- North Macedonia selects just Romani people crossing the border for quarantine in unhygienic conditions
- Czech ombudsman "likes" racist post on Facebook, refuses to answer questions about what that means
- Slovakia's TV Romana to be carried by the Orange TV satellite network
- Author raising a Romani child says Czech Public Defender of Rights is racist and evil is slowly winning
- Museum of Romani Culture to present its project for a Center of the Roma and Sinti in the Czech capital
- Czech ombudsman to control discrimination agenda, head of the legal section steps down to work for his deputy
- Hungarian PM announces "national consultation" about whether to compensate Romani families whose children were educated in segregated settings