Slovak Constitutional Court awards compensation to Roma for 13-year court case - but the discrimination sued over still has no final ruling
The Constitutional Court of the Slovak Republic has awarded compensation to four Romani plaintiffs for the delays they have experienced seeking redress for discrimination that happened almost 13 years ago. The plaintiffs filed suit after the personnel at a pub in a village near Vranov nad Topľou refused them service because of their ethnic origin in November 2005.
The Constitutional Court found several instances of misconduct by the lower courts that caused unnecessary delays in the proceedings, awarded each of the Romani plaintiffs EUR 1 000 in compensation for that misconduct, and ordered they be reimbursed the costs of bringing the lawsuit. They first filed in March 2006.
The case was one of the first about discrimination on an ethnic basis to be filed with the courts after the adoption of the Anti-Discrimination Act in 2004. The plaintiffs sought redress for discriminatory treatment they encountered at an establishment in the village of Čaklov.
"We were driving home that day from a business trip in Prešov and we stopped there to take a break. The personnel simply told us they do not serve Gypsies," one of the Romani plaintiffs recalled.
The District Court partially agreed with the plaintiffs more than once, but the Prešov Regional Court repeatedly overturned the lower court decisions. The Regional Court judgments were then themselves repeatedly overturned on appeal by the Supreme Court of the Slovak Republic.
In 2014 the Prešov Regional Court rejected the lower court's verdict a third time. The plaintiffs appealed in March of that year.
The District Court in Vranov nad Topľou then failed to provide the Supreme Court with what it needed to handle the appeal for more than four years. The entire court proceedings has taken 13 years so far.
In February 2018 the plaintiffs filed a constitutional complaint with the Constitutional Court of the Slovak Republic. They described the inaction of the lower courts as a violation of their right to have their case adjudicated without unnecessary delays.
The Constitutional Court ruling describes significant misconduct by the District Court which, after the Supreme Court returned the case file to it for completion in December 2014, failed to act on the matter for more than four years. "We are glad that after 13 years, this case has somehow moved forward. We continue to wait for the courts to finally rule on the discrimination perpetrated by the owner of the establishment, though. We thank our attorney for her cooperation and patience," the Romani plaintiffs said in a statement about the Constitutional Court ruling.
"This decision by the Constitutional Court has demonstrated how difficult and time-consuming it is - even 15 years after the adoption of the Anti-Discrimination Act - to achieve justice in discrimination cases in our country, especially in cases of racial discrimination. Such court proceedings frequently last an unbelievably long time. I do, however, perceive as very important that the injured parties, even after so many years, are continuing this case and demanding justice. Cases such as this facilitate the revelation of deficiencies in the assessment of discrimination cases by the courts, which can then be pointed out, and they create a certain pressure for the gradual improvement of the courts' decision-making practice," said the legal representative of the injured parties, Vanda Durbáková.
This is the second decision from the Constitutional Court in such a matter within a brief time recently. In March 2019 the court awarded compensation for delays in court proceedings to a Romani man who sought redress for discrimination in access to employment and whose case was ignored by the lower courts for years.
- Slovakia: Video of police intervention against Roma at gas station goes viral, sparks protests
- Slovak President: The Holocaust of the Roma cannot be forgotten, especially when hatred is becoming a political tool once more
- Infamous housing estate in Slovakia is finally turning around - continued
- Educator Martin Kaleja: From the Romani settlements in Slovakia to the Czech academic world
- Infamous housing estate in Slovakia is finally turning around
- Slovakia: Romani girl from settlement now champion runner in her region
- Slovak homeowner considers selling to Roma, so his neighbors graffiti his house and puncture his tires
- Slovakia: Dozens of children from orphanage ending up in psychiatric care - is it a business?
- Slovak Plenipotentiary for Romani Communities: We will focus on education and employment
- Czech film festival visited by seven Romani children from Slovak settlements to promote "Silent Days"
- Slovak Police arrest Czech citizen and two Slovak citizens on suspicion of extremism
- Slovak court grants early release to vigilante who murdered three Roma at their home, prosecutor complains
- Slovak President-elect creates minority adviser team, Roma represented by Jurina Rusnáková and Viktor Teru
- Slovak church bungles inclusion of Romani newcomer into First Communion ceremony, charges of racial discrimination being investigated
- Winner of Czech-Slovak singing competition "The Voice" subjected to racist attacks online
- EP elections: Four Romani candidates in Czech Republic, more than 20 in Slovakia
- Romani women call on Czech MPs to take the first step toward compensating forcibly, illegally sterilized persons, 150 figures support them
- More than 60 % of Czechs active online believe Romani people are favored over non-Roma in the Czech Republic
- Czech primary school materials feature a total of 71 sentences about Roma - and they promote stereotypes
- Czech school claims it's "random" that white children are segregated from Romani children in separate first-grade class
- European Court of Human Rights rules against Slovakia in case of police brutality against Roma
- Slovak President commemorates WWII-era National Uprising to which Roma also contributed
- Slovak project where Roma build their own homes seems more feasible in village setting, for now
- Best Reality, Stars reality corporation s.r.o., DůmRealit.cz, Broker´s Team, CENTURY 21 Finem caught on tape rejecting Roma tenants in Czech Republic, only CENTURY 21 apologizes
- Slovak tabloid covers funeral of Romani woman as spectacle
- Commentary: Czech ombudsman's racist remarks reveal his ignorance of Roma and of history
- Slovak survey of 450 settlements finds 80 % of households depend on borrowing money illegally
- Author Monika Duždová compares life for Romani people in England and Slovakia