Slovak court says school, not state, is responsible for segregating Romani children
According to the Prešov Regional Court in Slovakia, accountability for educating Romani children in segregated settings rests with individual schools, not with the state. Such a decision has been handed down in a case concerning a primary school in the village of Terňa.
The Center for Civil and Human Rights (Poradňa), which brought the lawsuit, has now appealed this second-instance decision. "Through our antidiscrimination public action we objected to the fact that, as a consequence of decisions made about the design of the school district, and as a consequence of the inaction of the state bodies that are responsible for oversight, a primary school in the village of Terňa is segregating Romani children. The Public Defender of Rights was also involved in bringing the lawsuit," said Štefan Ivanco, the organization's program coordinator.
The aim of those bringing the lawsuit was for the court to require the state bodies sued, i.e., the Education Ministry of the Slovak Republic and the District Authority in Prešov, to adopt effective measures to eliminate the state of unlawfulness at the school and to prevent segregation in future. The Regional Court's decision has upheld a February judgement from a District Court that rejected the lawsuit.
According to the first-instance ruling, the state administration is not authorized to intervene in the organization of the process of education, for which the school is the sole authority. According to the court, the segregation of Romani children into separate classes was not a consequence of decisions about the design of the school district.
The court found the state administration "had no choice" but to designate a common school district for the villages of Malý Slivník and Terňa, irrespective of the ethnicity of the schoolaged children living there. The villages are located close to each other in the microregion of Šariš in the District of Prešov and are listed in the Slovak Government's Atlas of Roma Communities.
"The appeals court, in its decision, did not actually question the fact that it is discriminatory to educate Romani children in a segregated setting, and did not question the fact that state institutions have an obligation to adopt measures to eliminate segregation," the human rights organization said in a press release. The judgment, according to them, contravenes international law, and for that reason the organization is planning to appeal to the Supreme Court.
"The appeals court, in the decision delivered to Poradňa, has sent the message, in principle, that if you want to address segregation in the schools, you must sue the schools responsible. By doing so, the court has narrowed down the legal interpretation of segregation to mean just the targeted separation of Romani children by schools into separate classrooms. The court ignored the fact that segregation in the schools frequently also results from measures adopted by state institutions or as a consequence of the inaction of state institutions. The institutions being sued in this specific case could have taken into account the available capacities of other schools and, through their decisions, could have designed a school district that would have made it possible for the primary school in Terňa to avoid segregation. I believe the Supreme Court of the Slovak Republic will overturn this decision and, should there be any doubt, will turn to the EU Court of Justice with a request for an analysis of the legal questions at issue in accordance with EU law," attorney Vanda Durbáková said.
- European Court of Human Rights rules against Slovakia in case of police brutality against Roma
- Slovak NGO reports that Romani children from excluded localities lack the online distance learning option
- Slovak Police refute disinformation alleging that rampaging murderer at school was Romani
- Slovak Education Ministry establishes expert team focused on solving problems with the education of members of national minorities
- Slovak Interior Ministry Inspectorate begins prosecution of officer who assaulted Romani children
- Slovak Government program declaration says it counts on improving the position of Romani people
- NGOs call on new Slovak Government to end the segregation of Romani children in education
- Romani competitive dancer Tomáš Kaluja aids non-Romani foster parents of Romani children in Slovakia with understanding ethnic identity
- European Court of Human Rights finds Slovak authorities did not properly investigate police brutality against Romani boy
- For a third time, Slovak court acquits police of brutalizing Romani children a decade ago, prosecutor appealing
- Slovak President Zuzana Čaputová met with Roma students on the occasion of World Roma Day
- Czech Constitutional Court sides with attorney Klára Kalibová: The criminality of hateful e-mails cannot be downplayed by the courts
- Slovak Govt Plenipotentiary for Romani Communities joins aid effort for refugees from Ukraine, monitoring patrols will make sure Romani refugees are assisted too
- Slovak firefighter tells ROMEA TV his remarks about Roma from Ukraine were based on what they themselves told him and the Czech reporter misunderstood him
- Slovak Interior Minister refuses to comment on firefighter's racist remarks about Romani refugees from Ukraine
- Commentary: Stop idealizing poverty
- Excluded Roma in Slovakia have died of COVID-19 more than non-Roma due to low rates of vaccination, their employment rates have also stagnated
- Czech Republic, Hungary, Slovakia: NGO reports that LGBT+ Roma face discrimination from their own families as well as majority societies in these EU Member States
- Czech court hands down three-year suspended sentence against man who approved of the Christchurch massacre
- Slovak Govt Plenipotentiary for Romani Communities Ján Hero: Census numbers do not reflect the actual number of Romani men and women here
- Slovak census: More than 156 000 people declared Romani nationality, more than 100 000 declared Romanes as their mother tongue
- Slovak NGO chair says half of all Romani women living in excluded communities experience domestic violence