UN Special Rapporteur on minority issues: The so-called “Roma issue” is not merely a poverty question
All Independent Experts of the UN are required by the Human Rights Council (HRC) to present annual reports on their work during one of the HRC's regular sessions in Geneva. Based on an HRC resolution adopted in 2014, the Special Rapporteur on minority issues, Dr Rita Izsák, was invited to present an additional study on the human rights situation of Roma worldwide, with a particular focus on the phenomenon of anti-Gypsyism.
Dr Izsák's presentation of that report and the subsequent response to it from the intergovernmental and state representatives present were broadcast live online earlier this month. During the response period the representative of Norway proposed that the Special Rapporteur on adequate housing and the Special Rapporteur on minorities undertake a joint report on that issue with respect to Romani people.
The European Roma Rights Centre interviewed Dr Izsák for its blog. News server Romea.cz reprints that interview here in full with permission:
ERRC: Can the problems of such a diverse group as the Roma be addressed by a global international organization?
RI: The term “Roma” in my report refers to heterogeneous groups, the members of which live in various countries under different social, economic, cultural and other conditions. It is therefore a multidimensional term that corresponds to the multiple and fluid nature of Roma identity. It refers to the multifaceted Roma universe, which is comprised of groups and subgroups that overlap but are united by common historical roots, traditions, culture, linguistic commonalities and a shared experience of discrimination.
ERRC: Do the Roma share the same experience of discrimination worldwide?
RI: In my study, I highlight that the lack of recognition of the fate of the Roma under the Nazi regime, often referred to as the “forgotten Holocaust”, has been identified as a major obstacle to restoring dignity and respect for the human rights of Roma worldwide. The 2nd of August is now officially Roma Holocaust Remembrance Day, and I believe there is a need to continue to bring heightened public attention to ensuring that the Roma Holocaust is appropriately commemorated.
ERRC: Are the problems of Roma different in Europe, Asia or the Americas?
RI: From my research, one of the main findings is that Roma communities and individuals around the world face deep-rooted problems of racism and extreme marginalization. In Europe, where the world’s largest Roma population lives, this remains a fact, despite a growing dedicated attention to the situation of Roma in recent years, and the establishment of numerous institutions and mechanisms to help address these deficiencies. While the reasons for the marginalization of Roma across the regions are complex, what I have identified is that throughout the world, Roma communities face deeply embedded social and structural discrimination and anti-Romani bias, which can be termed anti-Gypsyism. Although we must see that anti-Gypsyism is originally a European term, the discrimination it embodies manifests itself in a variety of ways across regions.
ERRC: Is anti-Gypsyism any different from any other racial bias?
RI: Anti-Gypsyism has been defined by the Council of Europe as “a specific form of racism, an ideology founded on racial superiority, a form of dehumanisation and institutional racism nurtured by historical discrimination, which is expressed, among others, by violence, hate speech, exploitation, stigmatisation and the most blatant kind of discrimination”. This entangled definition shows how complex and often elusive the discrimination against Roma is.
ERRC: What challenges do the Roma face globally?
RI: In my report I try to focus on the lessons learned, both globally and in particular from the European experience, to understand better why existing approaches have often not managed to bring about structural change for Roma communities. I emphasize that the so-called “Roma issue” is not merely a poverty question and that Roma communities should benefit from a wide range of minority rights protection measures. This includes protection of their existence, promotion of Roma identity and a need to have a holistic approach to the protection of their various civil, political, social, cultural and economic rights.
ERRC: How can we tackle challenges?
RI: In my study, I offer several recommendations that I regard key to achieving Roma inclusion, including the need for real political commitment, the importance of including Roma history and culture in school curriculums, the need to monitor and respond to hate speech and incitement to violence against Roma, to encourage Roma leadership, the creation of conditions for the effective participation of Roma in all aspects of life, and the establishment of dedicated institutional attention to Roma issues, just to mention a few.
ERRC: But why do Roma organizations often fail to make sustainable impact?
RI: In order to overcome disadvantages and marginalisation, Roma organisations need direct, accessible and sustainable funding sources. Projects with a focus of long-term sustainable change must be prioritized. Furthermore, clear information on exactly how much money is invested in what projects and how much of these have actually reached Roma communities must be transparent and readily available. Without such accountability, there is the risk of contributing to the perception that too many economic resources are invested in Roma with few results, which in turn further contributes to negative stereotypes about Roma.
ERRC: What is the responsibility of the majority in Roma inclusion?
RI: The absence of genuine and institutionalized political will to tackle Roma marginalization [means] the existence and success of Roma inclusion efforts may often depend heavily on the personal commitment of a particular political leader in power. Furthermore, as Roma are a disenfranchised minority group, they will often have little political influence or negotiating power at the local level.
ERRC: But how can the Roma get involved?
RI: Despite numerous new programmes and the unprecedented number of Roma intellectuals, professionals and activists around the world, Roma remain largely underrepresented or unrepresented in local and national bodies, and remain peripheral in regional and international decision-making bodies, not to mention institutions explicitly established to protect and promote their rights. Effective, meaningful participation should be a transformative process that becomes an inclusive experience, facilitating Roma involvement, empowerment and active citizenship. Such a participatory approach must also guarantee that those whose voices are rarely heard are empowered, including Roma women and young people.
ERRC: As a successful professional fighting for Roma emancipation on the global level how do you relate to your personal Roma heritage?
RI: It took some time for me to [come to] terms with this heritage. I think I could have chosen to live my life without openly disclosing my Roma background as my name and look do not necessarily make it obvious, but when I first told one of my bosses during my university years about my Roma ethnicity and [then] got dismissed from my workplace, I realized there is a battle to fight and I will have to take part in it with commitment, dignity and pride. This is what I hope I have been doing for many years now and I am grateful that my UN position allows me to do it globally before the Human Rights Council, which I believe can play a very crucial role in shedding light on this often-hidden plight of one of the world’s most marginalized groups.
- EU and UN criticize Hungary for local treatment of Roma and border fence plans
- UN side event on discrimination as a root cause of Romani marginalization
- VIDEO: UN Human Rights Council review of anti-Gypsyism
- UN Human Rights Council review of anti-Gypsyism will be webcast live next week
- Slovak homeowner considers selling to Roma, so his neighbors graffiti his house and puncture his tires
- Organizer of 8 July protest by Romani people in Brussels is corrected by incoming MEP - "I've never spoken with him"
- Slovak Police arrest Czech citizen and two Slovak citizens on suspicion of extremism
- Slovak court grants early release to vigilante who murdered three Roma at their home, prosecutor complains
- Czech Constitutional Court: Human rights defender has to count on "frustrated" people sending her death threats
- Antigypsyist hoax returns to Czech Internet alleging that Roma get free public transportation
- USA: Four-month-old Romani boy is youngest child to be separated from his parents at the border with Mexico
- US Holocaust Museum offers unique opportunity in Prague to relatives of those persecuted on Protectorate territory
- Slovak church bungles inclusion of Romani newcomer into First Communion ceremony, charges of racial discrimination being investigated
- "Romani Army" by Berlin-based Maxim Gorki Theater Company gets standing ovation at Czech festival
- Interview: Patriotism is not the same as hating those who are different
- EP elections bring two Romani men and one Romani woman to Brussels