Czech court upholds suspended sentence for man who called for non-white first-graders to be gassed to death
The suspended sentence for the author of hateful commentaries on social media posted beneath a photograph of first-graders attending a primary school in Teplice has now taken effect. The Regional Court in Ústí nad Labem has rejected the appeal of defendant Vítězslav Kroupa, who was sentenced for his hate speech on Facebook by the District Court in Teplice to 16 months in prison, suspended for three years.
The verdict has now taken effect and there is now only one other judicial option through which the defendant can complain about the outcome. "The appeals court reviewed the verdict in question and did not find the appeal justified," Judge Tomáš Plha said.
"There is no dispute over the fact that freedom of speech is constitutionally guaranteed, but such freedom is not boundless, it must not be abused and exploited in order to make extreme pronouncements, as in the case of the defendant," the judge said. The first-grade class at the Plynárenská Primary School was predominantly attended by children of Arab and Romani origin.
Kroupa posted his hateful commentary on social media beneath the children's class photograph in 2017. The District Court in Teplice first acquitted him one year ago, arguing that it had not been proven that he was the author of the speech in question.
That verdict was overturned on appeal and the case was returned to Teplice in order to complete discovery of the relevant facts. Judge Plha at the Regional Court has now ruled that the District Court in Teplice has followed all of the instructions of the appeals venue in that regard.
The District Court in Teplice pronounced its conviction of Kroupa in mid-July. According to the court, Kroupa made the following comments about the class photograph: "They're from the Plynárenská ["Gasworks"] Primary School. The solution is obvious."
According to Judge Lucie Yakut of the District Court in Teplice, it has been proven that the social media profile that published the comments belongs to Kroupa. He has been convicted of displaying sympathy for a movement aimed at suppressing human rights and freedoms and for the crime of inciting hatred against a group or inciting the restriction of their rights and freedoms.
Kroupa faced a prison sentence of anywhere between six months and three years for his actions and for the fact that he has posted the photographs of Adolf Hitler, Hermann Göring and the eagle of the German Reich holding a Nazi swastika on social media. Judge Yakut said a mitigating circumstance was the amount of time that has passed since the act was committed.
The judge did not consider the speech humorous, however. "Under no circumstances would it be possible to arrive at the conclusion that however inappropriate this comment by the defendant is, it constitutes a joke or a prank - this decidedly is not humor," Judge Yakut said.
According to Judge Plha, the appeals court also did not believe the comment could be read as a facetious work of art, as the appeals pleading argued. "The content of this commentary references a 'solution' in the form of murdering people in gas chambers, it is necessary to assess a reference to such a course of action as hate speech and incitement to hatred," he said.
Defense attorney Michael Mann had proposed additional evidence from an expert witness in the field of linguistics. The appeals court rejected that as superfluous.
"It is not possible to have any doubts as to the defendant's guilt," Judge Plha said. In his view, the kind of punishment handed down corresponds to the character and gravity of the felony committed.
- Exhibition in Czech capital shows newly-identified photographs of the deportations of Jewish people from Prague during the Holocaust
- Romani candidate for Czech Senate will not advance to the second round, but scores better than his extremist opponents
- Czech Senate election: Romani candidate says right-wing extremists could take power unless people vote for their competitors
- Commentary: What are the Romani candidates running for the fascists in the Czech Republic thinking?
- Czech court sentences perpetrator to five years for racist assault on Romani man, both defense and prosecution considering appeal
- Commentary: Work on antisemitism by US professor reminds us of antigypsyism in the Czech Republic today
- More Roma citizens of Romania attempting to cross from Mexico into the USA to seek asylum this year
- Football hooligans and neo-Nazis blame all Roma for violent crime and march through Czech town, riot police deployed
- Czech extremists move from inciting anti-Romani hatred to railing against "COVID terror" ahead of fall elections
- Czech appeals court exceptionally reduces sentence for social media user who approved of Christchurch massacre, notes current law is imbalanced
- After European Court of Human Rights ruling, Slovak court acquits yet another Romani victim wrongfully indicted for reporting a brutal police attack
- The ruling that took 15 years: Czech town ordered to compensate some of the Romani residents whom it evicted and relocated
- František Kostlán: Both the Jews and the Roma were victims of the Holocaust
- Czech lower house committee chooses attorney now facing disciplinary action for making light of racist crime to join public broadcasting board
- Czech court hands down sentencing in pool brawl case, one Romani man acquitted for having attempted to stop the altercation
- Czech court sentences brutal, racially-motivated assailant who attacked Romani man in front of children to 7.5 years in prison
- Czech footballer appeals UEFA ban, insists he never said anything racist
- Czech court gives suspended sentence to attacker who threatened to kill Romani women and their children with an ax