European Committee of Social Rights: Czech Republic overinstitutionalizes Romani children and children living with disabilities
The Council of Europe's Committee of Social Rights (ECSR) has criticized the Czech Republic for its "discriminatory and extensive" placement of children living with disabilities and Romani children into residential nursery institutions or centers designed for very young children. The problem, according to Anna Hofschneiderová of the NGO Forum for Human Rights (Fórum pro lidská práva), affects hundreds of children age three and younger who predominantly come from impoverished families.
"The Committee is criticizing the Czech Republic for having failed to adopt and incorporate into its regulations a corresponding... strategy," on this issue, the Committee's press release reads. According to the Committee, the Czech Republic is violating the rights of children, above all those three years of age and younger who are either living with disabilities or who are Romani, rights guaranteed by the European Social Charter of 1961.
The conclusions of the Committee are the consequence of a three-year-long investigation instigated by three NGOs. The European Roma Rights Centre (ERRC), the Forum for Human Rights (based in Prague) and the Validity Foundation (formerly the Mental Disability Advocacy Centre), jointly filed a collective complaint three years ago and provided evidence proving children's rights are being violated.
"The Committee's decision clearly means international law will not accept the ongoing placement of children into institutional care. States must arrange to provide the community services in the field that are essential to guaranteeing that children, especially those living with disabilities, and Romani children in particular, are able to grow up with caregivers who are loving and stable. We anticipate that the Czech Government will now head in that direction," emphasized the director of Validity, Ann Campbell.
"Institutions cause children harm, and from a legal standpoint, the Government is obliged to take all the necessary steps to change the existing system of care for young children. That systemic change must be based on the principle of all children having the right to enjoy living in a family environment," emphasized Maroš Matiaško, chair of the Forum for Human Rights.
"Romani children and children living with disabilities face disproportionate risks compared to the mainstream population when it comes to their care, and therefore states must arrange to provide the corresponding economic and social protections for young children. Special attention must be paid to disadvantaged and vulnerable groups of children," said Senada Sali of the ERRC.
The Committee's decision is based on three arguments. First, the Committee found the Czech Republic has failed in its attempts to reduce the number of young children living in institutions and in its attempts to arrange care for them on a community and/or family basis.
The conclusion drawn was that the existing Czech legal code facilitating the placement of vulnerable young children in institutions, as well as the constant maintenance of residential children's centers according to the law on healthcare services, is in violation of Article 17 of the European Social Charter. Secondly, the Committee found that the Czech Government has not yet undertaken any significant, targeted steps toward providing care to children in community/family settings instead of in institutions.
Thirdly, the Committee has also emphasized the significance of collecting the relevant data necessary to formulating appropriate policies and adopting corresponding steps. As the Czech Government was unable to provide any evidence or relevant information proving that it has attempted to improve the situation, it has violated the Charter on that score as well.
Prague is meant to arrange for a correction of the situation in response to the Committee's decision. The European Social Charter is a longstanding international agreement on economic and social rights.
Czechoslovakia signed the Charter in May 1992, and the independent Czech Republic then assumed its obligations. Fulfillment of the Charter is supervised by the ECSR.
- Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights calls on Czech lower house to adopt law to compensate illegally sterilized people, first reading scheduled for today
- Council of Europe says Czech Republic not doing enough to teach the Romani language
- Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights, Secretary General issue statements honoring 2 August
- Human Rights Commissioner of the Council of Europe calls for Romani living conditions to be improved during the COVID-19 pandemic
- Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe rapporteur: Instead of aiding Romani people during COVID-19, some European politicians are promoting antigypsyism
- Council of Europe Human Rights Commissioner welcomes Czech Govt purchase of pig farm on Romani genocide site
- Czech Republic to chair Council of Europe, claims human rights are a priority
- Secretary General of the Council of Europe warns its 47 member states against limiting democracy
- Council of Europe chief says discrimination against Romani people continues to be ignored
- Council of Europe honours victims and survivors of Roma Holocaust
- Council of Europe demands proof of changed practice in the Czech schools when it comes to Roma discrimination
- Yaron Matras: Do Roma need protection from themselves? The Council of Europe comes under fire from academics for reinforcing prejudice
- Council of Europe seeks independent, thorough investigation of the death of Romani community member Stanislav Tomáš in Teplice, Czech Republic
- Ladislav Samek: It is hard to get rid of the label of "institutionalized child" in Czech society
- Czech authorities could levy hefty fines against authors of discriminatory classified ads saying Roma need not apply
- More Roma citizens of Romania attempting to cross from Mexico into the USA to seek asylum this year
- Slovak public broadcasting continuing children's television program in Romanes and Slovak
- European Court of Human Rights finds Slovakia failed to properly investigate police brutality against Romani children
- Zeljko Jovanovic: The New Roma Politics of Self-Determination and Unity
- Slovak investigation into police beating of Romani children in quarantined settlement last year still ongoing
- Romani experts say Czech Government should supply for free the respirators it has made compulsory
- Czech NGO director tells ombudsman he should resign for refusing to acknowledge discrimination against Roma
- Alena Gronzíková: Czech landlords will not rent to Roma even with good references and steady incomes
- Romani people in the Czech Republic complain to retailers of security guards stalking them when they shop