Prague Forum for Romani Histories: Joint commemoration of the Jewish and Romani victims of the Holocaust should inspire others
According to the Prague Forum for Romani Histories (Pražské fórum pro romské dějiny - PFRD) the joint commemoration of the Jewish and the Romani victims of the Holocaust should become an inspiration and a model for other initiatives, whether at the local or the state level. The PFRD is responding to the decision taken by the board of directors of the Institute of the Terezín Initiative to no longer read the names of Romani victims of racial persecution during the Protectorate of Bohemia and Moravia as part of the commemorative reading of names of the dead on Yom Hashoah.
"The suffering of Roma and Sinti during the Second World War is, in the Czech Republic, still quite neglected and insufficently commemorated. For that reason, we appreciate all the more the fact that since 2010, at the instigation of the Union of Jewish Youth and in collaboration with the Foundation for Holocaust Victims, and after reaching agreement with representatives of the Romani community, the Institute of the Terezín Initiative decided to include the names of Holocaust victims of Romani origin among those being read," says the PFRD declaration, which has been made available to news server Romea.cz.
However, the PFRD does not agree with the critique of the board of directors of the ITI or of the Terezín Initiative accusing them of intolerance and racism. "We are convinced that when honoring the memories of Holocaust victims, who were, above all, Jews and Roma, it is necessary to respect the fact that both in the Jewish community and in the Romani community, voices will be logically and understandably raised to advocate for the commemoration and the honoring of the Holocaust victims of Jewish and Romani origin separately, as well as together," reads the statement, which news server Romea.cz is publishing here in full.
Prague Forum for Romani Histories on the debate around reading the names of Romani victims
Both the genocide of the Romani people and the history of the Roma in general continue to be marginalized subjects in Czech society, in school curricula and textbooks, and in the academic, cultural and public arenas. For that reason, in 2016, the Prague Forum for Romani Histories was established at the Institute of Contemporary History of the Academy of Sciences of the Czech Republic. As the representatives of this academic platform, we are publishing the following statement on the current debate about Yom Hashoah and reading the names of Romani victims on that occasion:
The suffering of Roma and Sinti during the Second World War is, in the Czech Republic, still quite neglected and insufficently commemorated. For that reason, we appreciate all the more the fact that, since 2010, at the instigation of the Union of Jewish Youth and in collaboration with the Foundation for Holocaust Victims, and after reaching agreement on this with representatives of the Romani community, the Institute of the Terezín Initiative decided to include the names of Holocaust victims of Romani origin among those being read aloud on Yom Hoshoah. We are of the opinion that the joint commemoration of the Jewish and the Romani victims of the Holocaust should inspire and become a model for other initiatives, whether at the local or the state level.
We consider the declaration by the new board of directors of the Institute of the Terezín Initiative dated 3 March 2021, according to which the board does not recommend reading the Jewish and Romani names together on Yom Hashoah this year, to be unfortunate. There do exist reasons why this memorial day could be reserved just for the Jewish victims, however. Yom Hazikaron laShoah ve-laG'vurah arose in the year 1951 in the state of Israel to commemorate the uprising in the Jewish ghetto in Warsaw, as a day to commemorate the Shoah and Jewish herosim during the war, alongside the more inclusively conceived International Holocaust Remembrance Day, which is also commemorated in Israel.
In the Czech Republic, however, thanks to the Institute of the Terezín Initiative and its close collaboration with the Union of Jewish Youth, since 2006 that day has become a day for reading the names of Holocaust victims aloud in public. It is quite important and rare that this custom has spread to dozens of towns in both Bohemia and Moravia where many civic initiatives participate in holding public readings of these names. Therefore, while Yom Hashoah was actually originally a day to commemorate Jewish victims specifically, here in the Czech Republic it has grown into a manifesto commemorating the victims of the Holocaust and racist policies generally, and it is sad that this rare initiative could be endangered by the decision of the ITI board of directors.
What is more, this year, when Yom Hashoah falls on 8 April, we are commemorating the 50th anniversary of the first World Roma Congress. In addition to agreeing on the form of the Romani flag, the Romani anthem and the uniform use of the term "Roma" during official negotiations, the delegates to that convention from different countries (many of whom were themselves survivors of the Second World War) commemorated the genocide of the Romani victims, which would not be acknowledged by many states for decades.
On the other hand, we consider it just as unfortunate that the board of directors of the ITI and the presidency of the Terezín Initiative, which brings together Jewish survivors of the Nazi ghettos in Łódź and Terezín (Theresienstadt), are being accused of intolerance and racism. What is more, this is happening in a situation when Czech society as a whole, and each of us as individuals, are failing to overcome the discrimination to which Romani people are subjected here on a daily basis.
We are convinced that when honoring the memory of Holocaust victims, who were, above all, Jews and Roma, it is necessary to respect the fact that both in the Jewish community and in the Romani community voices will be comprehensibly, logically raised to advocate for the commemoration and the honoring of the Holocaust victims of Jewish and Romani origin separately, as well as together. There is no doubt that both kinds of commemoration are important. Above all, however, the commemoration of Holocaust victims should not be the exclusive affair of either the Jewish or the Romani community, but of all of Czech society.
On behalf of the Prague Forum for Romani Histories:
Mgr. Renata Berkyová
Kateřina Čapková, PhD
- Terezín Initiative in Czech Republic does not want Romani names included in Shoah commemoration, director of its Institute disagrees
- Internet connects Holocaust remembrance sites to commemorate deaths of Theresienstadt "Family Camp" inmates at Auschwitz-Birkenau
- Speaker of the Czech Senate and Romani representative on the importance of Holocaust commemoration for ROMEA TV
- Czech Romani group objects to reading names of Holocaust victims who were Romani, those organizing commemorations disagree
- Exhibition in Czech capital shows newly-identified photographs of the deportations of Jewish people from Prague during the Holocaust
- Czech town to see exhibition by pro-Romani and Romani artists referencing the Black Lives Matter movement
- Czech website on the Holocaust launches database of victims labeled "cikáni" by the Nazis and their accomplices
- Czech commemoration at site of Nazi massacre tomorrow will not feature xenophobic speaker
- Open Letter: Conveners of Holocaust commemoration are too quiet after politician disgraced it
- Czech descendants of WWII resistance fighters demand senator resign over speech at Holocaust memorial
- Czech Senator compares environmental, gender equality, multiculturalism advocacy to racism and totalitarianism at Holocaust site
- EU: Half of the population perceives antisemitism as a problem
- Monika Mihaličková to the Czech Senate: Election laws must not allow the horrors of the Holocaust to repeat
- Czech civil society groups, Romani ones included, protest students inviting ultra-right candidate to debates ahead of elections
- Week-long education event at Terezín also honors genocide of Roma with concert and flag
- Třebíč, Czech Republic commemorates anniversary of Holocaust transports from there
- Stanislav Tomáš, who died in police custody, laid to rest in Teplice, Czech Republic. Civil society and his family call for his death to be properly investigated
- Romani residents of infamous Czech housing estate are repairing dilapidated buildings themselves with the help of the town hall
- 70+ Romani students attending Czech colleges applied to the ROMEA organization's scholarship program this year
- Czech Senate committee recommends compensation for the illegally sterilized, final word will rest with the Senate as a whole
- Czech Police reject request for a second autopsy of the late Stanislav Tomáš, whose funeral will take place on Saturday, 24 July
- NGOs from four countries reject David Mezei's threats and vulgar attacks as endangering the investigation of the death of Stanislav Tomáš
- Czech attorney for the family of Stanislav Tomáš has requested a second autopsy - Romea.cz refutes disinformation being spread by Facebook LIVE broadcasters
- Staffers of the Institute of the Terezín Initiative in the Czech Republic are outraged by the board's dismissal of director, fear Holocaust victims' database could be endangered
- Terezín Initiative in the Czech Republic dismisses director of its Institute, she considers her dismissal incorrect, invalid and unfair
- Czech local archive publishes digitalized records online of the former concentration camp for Romani people at Lety
- Romani community members rescue children from apartment fire on Czech housing estate
- Kosovo: Demonstrators call for investigation into the death of Stanislav Tomáš, who died in police custody in Teplice