Czech Government is neutral on introducing public interest prosecutions of discrimination
A bill in the lower house of the Czech Parliament to introduce public interest prosecutions of discirmination will be neither rejected nor supported by the Government of ANO and the Czech Social Democratic Party (ČSSD). At the cabinet meeting on 10 April ministers adopted a neutral stance on the bill.
The proposed template would shift the burden of proof from those suing to those being sued in all individual disputes falling under the Antidiscrimination Act. The right to file a public interest prosecution, according to the bill drafted by a group of MPs from the governing parties plus the opposition Pirates, would be granted to NGOs involved in defending the rights of victims of discrimination.
Those groups would be able to ask a court to decide whether discrimination had happened or not, to rule that it must end, and to rule that the consequences of the discrimination must be eliminated. "Prosecutions seeking the restoration of a previous state of affairs or designation of discrimination are not appropriate for public interest prosecution in the form proposed, as they already assume there is a much greater interest in the outcome of the proceedings by those impacted without their having any kind of guaranteed position in the proceedings," the Government's legislative analysts wrote about the bill.
Analysts also cast doubt on the provision stating that if the prosecution were to mention a specific person as having been discriminated against, that person would have to agree with the filing of the prosecution in advance. That arrangement could lead to the erroneous impression that the nonprofit organizations would actually represent the individual in the proceeding, the legal analysts say.
Public interest prosecutions could, according to the bill, target possibly discriminatory behavior affecting a bigger number of people or cases of unequal treatment that could, due to their extent and social impact, significantly endanger the public interest. Currently lawsuits against discrimination can only be filed by individuals.
"Prosecutions in the public interest can reduce the amount of lawsuits filed in each individaul case of discrimination and thereby also relieve the overburdened courts, as well as save money on the cost to each party of conducting a dispute," the authors of the bill wrote. Such public interest prosecutions could, in their view, be of a preventive character also.
The cabinet recalled, in association with that aspect, that it is currently planning to introduce the option of collective action, of which victims of discrimination could also take advantage. Shifting the burden of proof for all discrimination disputes is justified by those submitting the bill through their allegation that the current form of the law disadvantages some vulnerable groups of people, for example, people living with disabilities or senior citizens.
Currently, shifting the burden of proof only happens in disputes about racial discrimination, employment or professional discrimination, or unequal access to goods and services based on sex. The Chamber of Commerce of the Czech Republic recommended the Government reject the bill.
"Today prosecutions to defend the public interest in administrative jurisprudence are already available to the Public Defender of Rights and the State Prosecutor, so the question, therefore, is why they should be made newly available to nonprofit organizations. Also, the fines levied by auditing bodies in cases of proven discrimination, whether involving a specific individual or an unspecified number of persons, are currently sufficient," Miroslav Diro, press spokesperson for the Chamber of Commerce, said in a press release.
- Czech Trade Inspection Authority found 13 cases of consumer discrimination last year - "No Roma, no young children..."
- LIVE BROADCAST TODAY AT 16:00 in Prague: RomanoNet protests discrimination and racism against Roma in Europe, publishes manifesto Dost! Basta! Enough!
- LIVE BROADCAST: EU Fundamental Rights Agency publishes findings on discrimination of minorities in the EU
- European Parliament: Roma in the EU face antigypsyism and everyday discrimination that must stop
- Czech Republic: Yet another audio recording documents real estate agent discrimination against Roma
- Czech nonprofit real estate agency helps people facing discrimination find housing
- Gwendolyn Albert: Is impunity ending for ethnic discrimination in the Czech schools?
- US State Department reproaches Czech Republic over corruption, discrimination against Romani people
- Czech court reviews alleged racial discrimination during first-grade enrollments
- Czech inspectors issue discrimination fines: Foreigners charged more, Roma refused service
- LIVE WEBCAST: OSCE conference reviews the rights of the child today and will touch on the discrimination of Romani children in education
- Council of Europe chief says discrimination against Romani people continues to be ignored
- ROMEA releases new Czech-Norwegian documentary film about aid for victims of discrimination and hate violence
- Council of Europe demands proof of changed practice in the Czech schools when it comes to Roma discrimination
- Czech expert says child welfare authorities should address discrimination in the schools
- Analysis: Czech daily reprints eight-year-old dissenting opinions of Strasbourg judgment on racial discrimination in education
- Thirty years of freedom: Roma in the Czech Republic wanted totalitarianism to end, value the chance to do business, lament antigypsyism
- Czech Regional Court returns online hate speech case about death threats against first-graders to lower court, more evidence needed
- Michal Mižigár: What democracy brought us Romani people in the Czech Republic in the 1990s
- Lifeguard gets state honors from Czech President for injuries sustained in brawl that sparked ultra-right anti-Romani demonstration
- Pavel Botoš: Who will stop the use of terms like "cigoši" in the Czech Republic?
- Iveta Bílková: Czech society should not tolerate words like "Cigán", "Cigoši", etc.
- Roma are most frequently targeted by hatred on the Czech Internet, experts say the law applies online too
- Patrik Banga: Social media is depriving us of context and driving us all crazy
- Spanish MP of Romani origin calls on OSCE to focus on greater participation of Roma in politics
- Czech court gives suspended sentences and fines to "Bloc against Islamicization" followers over death threats to random pedestrians
- Czech court frees women charged with promoting Nazism more than a decade ago
- Czech court acquits man of using force against two racists who insulted him