Czech Supreme Audit Office: People who are not disadvantaged at all are being awarded "social housing"
State-subsidized apartments are being leased by people in the Czech Republic who are not living with any kind of medical or social disadvantage. What's more, the Czech Regional Development Ministry is not keeping track of who is actually taking advantage of such subsidized properties.
Those are the findings of the Supreme Audit Office (Nejvyšší kontrolní úřad - NKÚ), which is also criticizing the Regional Development Ministry's expenditures on discounted mortgages for young home buyers. NKÚ spokesperson Olga Málková reported on the results of the audit today.
The office discovered that the state's entire concept for supported housing had been developed for the State Fund for Housing Development by an external firm at a cost of more than CZK 2 million (EUR 74 000) - even though that fund has not been tasked with anything else besides addressing that issue. "The concept, however, does not include indicators for assessing whether its aims for supporting housing have been met or not," the NKÚ said.
The Czech state has invested more than CZK 8.3 billion (EUR 307 million) into supporting housing since 2011 and the European Union has contributed almost CZK 5 billion (EUR 185 million) more during that time. The Regional Development Ministry has allocated almost CZK 4.9 billion (EUR 181 million) to support the construction of 9 453 apartment units to be leased by people living with either medical or social disadvantage.
"Those applying to finance subsidized apartments for the disadvantaged do not have to subsequently prove whether the apartments are actually needed in a given locality. Once they get the financial support, the ministry does not follow up on whether the apartments actually are being taken advantage of by tenants living with medical or social disadvantage," the NKÚ reports.
Comptrollers from the NKÚ audited nine randomly-chosen projects. Those receiving subsidies for a total of 71 new or reconstructed apartment units were leasing them to people who did not qualify as part of the target group.
"One of the subsidy recipients audited, for example, was leasing just one of its nine subsidized apartments to a disadvantaged tenant, even though the recipient reported leasing all nine units to people from the target group," the NKÚ said. The audit also discovered suspicions that three subsidy recipients had broken the rules for budget discipline to the tune of more than CZK 8.5 million (EUR 314 000).
One subsidy recipient, for example, received funds that exceeded the actual project cost by more than CZK 100 000 (EUR 3 700). The audit also found that the Regional Development Ministry paid more to administer its program offering discounted mortgages to persons 36 years of age and younger than it ever disbursed in financial benefits to those taking out such mortgages.
From 2011-2015 the ministry did not provide any contributions toward mortgages for new applicants, but the banks received more than CZK 37 million (EUR 1.4 million) to administer applications from clients who were not entitled to claim a contribution because their existing mortgage interest rates were already low. Between 1997 and 2012 the Czech state had already invested almost CZK 138 billion (EUR 5 billion) into support for housing.
- Czech Labor and Social Affairs Ministry plans financing of social housing as discussion of new law proceeds
- Czech Platform for Social Housing: Fire shows children must be rescued from living in residential hotels
- Czech Platform for Social Housing chair: Roma in residential hotels need a chance at a dignified life
- Struggle over Czech social housing law begins
- Czech Republic: From anti-Romani demos to lack of social housing law, social inclusion is slow
- 2015 issues for Romea.cz: "Practical schools" and social housing
- Czech Govt Agency for Social Inclusion director says normal housing is the best gift for children in residential hotels
- Czech Platform for Social Housing position paper calls for permanent housing
- Czech social housing responsibility may shift to municipalities
- Commentary: Deadline for adopting Czech social housing concept is unrealistic
- Czech commission plans to draft social housing plan by year-end
- Czech court annuls board of directors of Ústecký Region's biggest housing cooperative
- VIDEO: Ostentatious homes built by Roma community in Romania reflect their desire for prestige
- Infamous housing estate in Slovakia is finally turning around - continued
- Czech institute says city's hope of state investment into "container" housing may be in vain
- Prague City Council disagrees with Czech bill to consolidate two housing benefits into one
- Roma forced into "container" housing by Czech mayor a decade ago warn others it's not fit for human habitation
- Jan Husák: Is the current Labor and Social Affairs Minister really worse than the worst-ever holder of that office?
- Czech Labor and Social Affairs Minister claims "disruptive" change to housing benefits won't harm families or senior citizens
- Platform for Social Housing calls on Czech Labor Minister to withdraw her cancellation of housing benefits
- Czech Govt Agency for Social Inclusion does not support new investment into infamous housing estate properties
- Czech Labor and Social Affairs Ministry plans to abolish existing housing benefits
- Czech Pirate Party starting new approach to social inclusion of Roma in northern town