Roma are most frequently targeted by hatred on the Czech Internet, experts say the law applies online too
Anonymity online is frequently not what it seems, and those who post hateful content have to know that they can be tracked and held accountable for it, according to Supreme State Prosecutor Pavel Zeman, who spoke at a conference about "Hatred on the Internet" today at the Czech Constitutional Court. Zeman said Romani people continue to be the most frequent targets of hateful prejudice on the Czech Internet, although verbal attacks against Jews and Muslims are also increasing.
The Supreme State Prosecutor said it is necessary to publicly discuss this subject and for convictions punishing hate speech online to be publicized. The vast majority of such verdicts have been handed down against male perpetrators, only a few of whom are recidivists - most of the time they are "ordinary people", according to the Office of the Public Defender of Rights, which has analyzed Czech court decisions in such matters.
"People have to know that the Internet is not anonymous, that what they write there remains available, that it is searchable, and that they are liable for it, very often even criminally liable," said Zeman. Czech Public Defender of Rights Anna Šabatová said: "The public must be informed that the law applies on the Internet too."
Zeman called hate speech a contemporary illness that must be cured, otherwise it can proceed to the next phase and lead to actions such as the recent attack on the synagogue in Halle, Germany. When prosecuting unlawful online hate speech, police and prosecutors must apply new methods and should adapt their work to the characteristics of the online space, Zeman said.
However, he also said that repression by the criminal justice authorities is not the only cure, but is rather an extreme solution. What is important is prevention, public education, and reaching people in their homes and in the schools.
According to Šabatová, hate speech has to be categorically condemned by academics and politicians, who have a social responsibility to do so. "There are few problems in our times that have disturbed me as much as the dissemination of hatred on the Internet," she said.
"The mass nature of the communication and the partial anonymity seduce people to spew remarks that are so disgusting and inhumane that they take your breath away," the Public Defender of Rights noted. Hatred, in her view, influences the atmosphere in society.
Šabatová expressed concern for the younger generation, who could consider hateful remarks the norm by now. The President of the Czech Constitutional Court, Pavel Rychetský, spoke and also described his shock when discussion spaces online were first opened up beneath articles on the websites of serious newspapers.
"Never before had I ever seen or heard such concentrated malice, vulgarity, insults, attacks on the most intimate aspects of the human personality, creepy behavior, half-truths and lies, all mixed into a poisonous swamp of anonymous discussion participants," Rychetský said. He them emphasized that he "hates censorship".
However, in his view, it is necessary to find ways to defend individuals' right to express their opinions while preventing the dissemination of opinions promoting racism, xenophobia, and all forms of hatred. "Does the right to hate exist?" he asked.
"Do we have the freedom to be evil? If it is possible to defend against this, then by what means and with what power?" the President of the Czech Constitutional Court asked those assembled.
Rychetský added that the law, in his view, is lagging behind technological development "by several horse lengths". Constitutional Court Justice Kateřina Šimáčková also spoke and said she herself has faced hateful attacks after handing down several decisions, with people writing to her to say they hope that she burns in hell or will be raped.
Generally, Šimáčková said she believes that these hateful remarks are frequently being voiced by people who are frustrated and unhappy. "It's necessary to deal with the reasons for their frustration," the justice said.
Šimáčková also said she believes it is the job of legal professionals and the state to clarify the limits of criminal speech. Awareness must be raised about where the limits of unlawfulness might lead - what it is possible to debate and what will be considered a crime, she said.
- Czech politician who relies on hatred ties himself in knots over the ultra-right terrorism in Germany
- Hate Killer 3000! campaign reminds bystanders in the Czech Republic how to stand up to hate
- International Network against Cyber Hate and ROMEA hold conference on antigypsyism and online hate in Czech capital
- European Roma are sharing an online hoax from 2002 about poisonous cosmetic samples
- Jarmila Balážová, renowned journalist from the Romani community, joining commercial Czech online news server
- Czech court overturns acquittal for author of racist online comments, prosecution will continue
- Czech ultrachauvinist shares satire online - without getting the joke
- Czech Prosecutor General insists online hate speech is a felony, Supreme Court agrees
- Czech Police, prosecutors intensively focus on online haters, number of prosecutions rising
- Antigypsyist hoax returns to Czech Internet alleging that Roma get free public transportation
- Unsubstantiated allegations about democratic parties being shared by Czech Internet users in the runup to European elections
- Governments, Internet firms ally forces against extremist, violent content
- Czech court gives former secretary to ultra-right party suspended sentence for inciting hatred
- US State Department says Czech Republic is grappling with anti-Roma hatred, including from the President
- Czech Internet trolls have competition - "elves" are combating disinformation and propaganda
- New York Times: Social network operators do not know how to intervene against disinformation and hatred
- Romani doctor in Czech Republic will get vaccinated and is disturbed by COVID-19 disinformation
- Volunteer civil society members of Czech Govt Roma Council: ombudsman intentionally undermining the dignity of Romani people
- Czech ombudsman criticizes draft Roma Strategy, rejects idea of updating information about compensation for forced sterilizations
- The other Czech pandemic: Disinformation about anti-COVID vaccination. Romea.cz refutes the most frequent hoaxes and manipulations
- Czech racists hated Vodafone Christmas ad featuring non-white children, the company objects to their online comments
- Scandalous fourth acquittal by Czech court of racist football fans accused of assaulting Black man on tram
- Czech court gives suspended sentence to adults who assaulted young Romani children physically and verbally in a park last year
- German court sentences terrorist who attacked Halle synagogue last year to life in prison
- Racists in Czech capital assault non-white family, call the father "Cikán", give the Nazi salute, try to take their baby
- Older Romani woman recounts how security guards in Czech shop saved her from violent racist thug
- Bulgarian COVID-19 pandemic measures have closed Romani neighborhoods, causing job losses and food shortages
- Romani politicians: Slovak court's judgment in case of police abuse of children is unacceptable