Czech court rules in favor of songwriter's widow, xenophobic band loses prize named after him without authorization
The Czech organization that gave a music award named after the songwriter Karel Kryl to the frontman for the xenophobic Ortel band, Tomáš Ortel, have lost their appeal of the lawsuit filed against them by the songwriter's widow. The Gold Award for the Legacy of Karel Kryl was given to Ortel last spring by a group called People to People (Lidé lidem) that actually was not authorized to use the songwriter's name at all.
The Regional Court in Plzeň handed down its ruling against the award-givers on 20 June. The District Court there first banned them from abusing Kryl's name in October 2017.
That first-instance court also instructed those convicted of wrongdoing to apologize to Kryl's widow. The organization then appealed.
"There are no grounds for the defendant to appeal," Regional Court Judge Lubomír Fiala said on 20 June. The group was sued by the widow of Karel Kryl, Magdalena Krylová, for using his name without permission.
Kryl's widow did not like her husband's name being abused for political agitation in connection with the controversial Ortel band. According to Prague-based attorney Tomáš Bejček, who is representing the widow in court, the group abused the name and personality of Karel Kryl and denigrated his dignity, honor, memory and seriousness.
"The award was meant to celebrate the memory of Karel Kryl. He was a dissident, which can also be said of Tomáš Ortel. Both of them went against the establishment," the attorney for the sued award-givers, Oldřich Lukáš, told news server novinky.cz.
Lukáš has previously called the lawsuit an attack. "So, the dark sun-worshippers (the optimists, those who loaf around in Prague cafes, and other traitors from the hatchery of Kalergi and the fans of Soros) have managed to get us where they wanted - on the edge of total destruction. This has happened through the lawsuit of Magdalena Kryl (his widow, who lived with Karel during the last two years of his life in Germany) over the fact that we have proposed awarding Tomáš Ortel the Gold Award for the Legacy of Karel Kryl for his patriotic songs," he wrote last November about the collections order placed on the association in a text asking for aid with paying off his friends' debts.
According to news server novinky.cz, Bejček pointed to Hnídek's past when explaining the widow's argument to the court. "He was a performer in the band Conflict 88, which is basically a neo-Nazi group," the attorney said.
The lyrics of that band were antisemitic and racist. The double 8 in its name is code for the Nazi greeting "Heil Hitler", as "H" is the eighth letter of the alphabet.
Lukáš objected in court to the characterization of Ortel's lyrics as racist and xenophobic. The representatives of the award-givers, according to him, are convinced that Karel Kryl is a famous celebrity whose art is part of the cultural wealth of the country.
"His spiritual legacy belongs to the entire nation," the defense attorney alleged. Ortel, whose birth name was Tomáš Hnídek, comes from Plzeň.
During the last three years of the "Czech Nightingale" music competition Ortel has won two bronze nightingale and one silver nightingale in the category of Male Vocalist. In April he got married at Zbiroh Chateau in the Rokycany area, where the SS command was headquartered during the Second World War, on Adolf Hitler's birthday.
- Czech documentary shows illegal Nazi salute being given at concert by xenophobic Ortel band
- Romani celebrity faces racist comments, death threats from fans of xenophobic band Ortel
- Czech xenophobic band Ortel nominated by public again for music award
- Czech Republic: Fans of neo-Nazi band Ortel attack foreign-born food servers
- Czech courts definitively acquit publisher of Salafist book of promoting a movement against human rights
- Polish prosecutor investigating anti-Jewish demonstration at the gates of Auschwitz
- Czech university sponsors art project referencing opponent of Hitler in town known for its intolerance
- EU: Half of the population perceives antisemitism as a problem
- Complaint against racist election campaign in Czech town heads to the European Court of Human Rights
- Czech terrorist gets four years, judge says he was influenced by the public dissemination of extremism
- European Court of Human Rights: Slovakia did not sufficiently investigate racial motivation of shooting six years ago
- Czech Supreme Court to review verdict in shooting murder of Romani man in Chomutov
- Hungarian Supreme Court says camerawoman who kicked asylum-seekers committed misdemeanor and can no longer be prosecuted
- Romani musician Ida Kelarová on verdict against gunman: We're disappointed the Czech court ignored the racist motivation
- USA: Shooter at synagogue in Pittsburgh remanded into custody without bail
- Czech Constitutional Court president: Ethnic and national self-centeredness and xenophobia are a threat to Europe