Czech Interior Minister suing City of Prague over opinion on gallows at demonstration
The Office of the Municipal Department of Prague 1 did not make an error when it failed to assess the presence of a mock-up of a gallows during a demonstration against migration last year as constituting a misdemeanor, according to Prague City Hall, which has now reviewed the appeal of that Prague 1 decision filed by Czech Interior Minister Milan Chovanec (Czech Social Democratic Party - ČSSD), who says he will now file an administrative lawsuit over City Hall's decision. Chovanec says he believes threatening people with a gallows in public must not be allowed to be considered legal.
Carrying a gallows to a demonstration and publicly threatening anybody in the Czech Republic with it, in the view of the Interior Minister, crosses the line on freedom of speech. He believes such behavior should be assessed as a misdemeanor at the very least.
Chovanec announced his plans in a press release. The incident happened in the center of Prague last July, when several hundred people were protesting against immigration and the refugee resettlement quotas proposed by the EU.
Some demonstrators brought mock-ups of gallows with them, inscribed with "For Treason", which they believed some Czech politicians had committed through their actions on those issues. "I cannot identify with this argument [of City Hall], especially at a time when extremists are radicalizing and are not hesitating to use violence. On the basis of the opinions and recommendations of the Interior Ministry's legislative experts, therefore, I will file an administrative lawsuit against this decision by the City of Prague," the Interior Minister's press release reads.
Chovanec also mentioned that the Prague 1 authorities based their decision solely on assessing the testimony of the suspects involved. He believes the administrative bodies never attempted to sufficiently ascertain what the actual state of affairs was with respect to the incident.
The Interior Ministry said it would now be familiarizing itself with Prague City Hall's justifications of its decision in more detail once it has obtained the written judgment. In a related court case, Judge Jarmila Löffelmannová also referenced the seriousness of the presence of the gallows during the public event.
Earlier this month the judge handed down a decision acquitting activist Kateřina Krejčová, who had counter-protested that particular demonstration against Islam and migration, of allegedly assaulting a police officer during those events. When handing down her verdict, the judge said it had been unfair of the lower court to punish Krejčová for sitting on the sidewalk to block the demonstration when police officers had ignored the much more serous criminal activity being perpetrated by the demonstrators whom the activist was counter-protesting.
The judge also criticized the decision by the Czech Police's own internal audit office, which ruled that it had not been a felony for the demonstrators to threaten people with the gallows during the public event. Krejčová (age 30) and a small group of other people counter-protested because they wanted to express their disagreement with the demonstration against immigration and refugee reception quotas.
According to the indictment, of which she was later acquitted, Krejčová allegedly assaulted a police officer after he knelt on top of her boyfriend as he was prone on the ground, knocking one of his teeth out. According to the final verdict of the Prague Municipal Court, however, that incident did not constitute an attack because the activist was incapable of causing the police officer any harm.
Krejčová is now suing the District Directorate of Police for Prague 1 and the Regional Directorate of the Prague Police over the incident. That case will come to trial on 15 June.
- Czech Interior Ministry appealing municipal decision on gallows at anti-refugee hate demonstration
- Czech state prosecutor says gallows at demonstration was illegal
- Czech Police audit says officers proceeded correctly at demonstration with mock-ups of gallows
- Czech Police now agree that "a gallows has no place in a democracy"
- Commentary: Are the Czech police not bothered by death threats and a gallows?
- Commentary: Actually, the Czech Police do not "know" that a gallows has no place in a democracy
- Czech Prime Minister: Police procedure during demonstration with gallows was absurd
- Czech Interior Minister says police should know a gallows has no place in a democracy
- Czech State Security Council takes note of extremism report as originally worded, Czech President did not get his way
- Hundreds of convicted German neo-Nazis evading custody, some may be in the Czech Republic
- Czech intelligence: "Pure pragmatists" overtaking traditional extremists could be exploited by the Kremlin
- Analysis: Quo vadis, Jobbik? Hungary's ultra-right moves to the center
- Czech principal says politicians forgot about her school after death threats were made against it last year
- Czech town sees low turnout for 10th anniversary of anti-Romani pogrom, Romani people light candles for the police officers injured that day
- Czech prosecutor to review police decision not to charge politicians over remarks about Romani genocide site
- Czech ultra-right extremists plan to commemorate 10th anniversary of their attempted pogrom on Romani people
- Commentary: Actual risk now exists that deniers of the Holocaust of the Roma could join the Czech Government
- Czech Constitutional Court receives complaint about election campaign, proposals for "fertilization" of "gypsies" recur in local media discussion
- Czech trial of racist assault on Prague tram: Eyewitnesses can still come forward, next hearing in January
- Hungarian Supreme Court says camerawoman who kicked asylum-seekers committed misdemeanor and can no longer be prosecuted