Czech Supreme Court upholds sentence for hate posted about non-white first-graders: Not a joke, but the promotion of Nazism
The comment posted online beneath a photograph of first-graders in a primary school in Teplice, Czech Republic was hate speech and cannot be considered "black humor" or protected by freedom of speech, according to the Czech Supreme Court, which has rejected the appeal of Vítězslav Kroupa, who has been sentenced to 16 months in prison, suspended for three years, for the post. The court's decision was handed down this summer without being publicized and its full justification has now been made available.
The first-grade class at the Plynárenská Street Primary School was predominantly attended by Arab and Romani children. "They're from the Plynárenská ["Gasworks"] Primary School. The solution is obvious," Kroupa commented beneath a photograph of the class on Facebook.
The Czech Supreme Court said Kroupa's comment indicated an opportunity to annihilate "undesirable ethnicities" in gas chambers, i.e., to do this in the same way that the Nazis systematically murdered Jewish people and others during the Second World War. "In a democracy under the rule of law, based on respect for constitutionally-guaranteed civil and human rights, such remarks are unacceptable and it is necessary to respond to them by prosecuting them," their decision reads.
The defense had alleged that Kroupa's comment was "black humor". The Czech Supreme Court did not find that argument credible and rejected the option of linguistic analysis to that effect being submitted as expert testimony.
"This was absolutely, unequivocally not about humor, and not just because of the absence of emoticons, but primarily because of the overall context in which the comment was written and into which it was inserted, as well as with regard to the ultra-right orientation of the accused," the judges said. According to his appeal, Kroupa believes he has essentially been convicted of holding "incorrect opinions", but even that is not true, according to the Czech Supreme Court.
"The holding of certain values or opinions is not an offense that is prosecutable and cannot be. On the other hand, the public incitement of hatred, or the display of sympathy for hateful movements, must be prosecuted under the conditions established through the Criminal Code," the judges wrote in their decision. Kroupa was also convicted of publishing an image of the Nazi Reich eagle holding the Nazi swastika as well as publishing portraits of convicted Nazi war criminal Hermann Göring and Adolf Hitler through social media.
When Kroupa posted a photo of Hitler raising his right arm in the Nazi salute, he added the comment: "Have beautiful white dreams, Friends." In his appeal, Kroupa's defense attorney reproached the lower court judges for not specifying the concrete movement of which Kroupa is a sympathizer in their verdict.
The defense alleged that referring to the "contemporary neo-Nazi scene" is insufficient because the Nazism represented by Göring and Hitler is a dead movement. The Czech Supreme Court upheld the lower court verdict in that regard as well.
"The neo-Nazi movement as a whole is by no means a 'dead' movement and it exists today as well, although the original movement (German Nazism) upon which the neo-Nazi movement is based no longer exists," the decision says. According to the Czech Supreme Court, Kroupa's verbal and visual messages on social media are the "absolutely plain and simple promotion of neo-Nazism".
- Czech Bar Association reprimands attorney for approving of "joke" calling for the gassing of non-white first-graders, he appeals
- Jaroslav Miko: Czech President shows his arrogance and lack of basic social empathy on the first day of school
- Czech court sentences social media user to two years in prison, suspended for two years, for promoting terrorism
- Woman says intercity bus driver in northern Czech town racially abused her and called for the death of all Roma before physically throwing her onto a road
- Grandson of famous Czechoslovak partisan from the Romani community says his grandfather was a hero
- Editor-in-Chief of Czech media outlet appeals direct sentencing for publishing antigypsyist content, the case will be heard in open court
- Out-of-town youth assault Romani child and then other Roma in Sokolov - Czech Police defused the conflict and are investigating, local Roma not happy with their response
- Stanislav Tomáš, who died in police custody, laid to rest in Teplice, Czech Republic. Civil society and his family call for his death to be properly investigated
- Justice for Stanislav. Family of the late Romani man from Teplice, Czech Republic publishes obituary, funeral will be Saturday
- Commentary: Bias-motivated violence targets identity and includes the bullying or distrust many in the Czech Republic consider normal
- Czech Labor and Social Affairs Ministry reports that 53 % of under-threes in infant facilities are Romani
- Czech Police reject request for a second autopsy of the late Stanislav Tomáš, whose funeral will take place on Saturday, 24 July
- Czech attorney for the family of Stanislav Tomáš has requested a second autopsy - Romea.cz refutes disinformation being spread by Facebook LIVE broadcasters
- Czech social media response to tornado includes antigypsyist rushes to judgment about Romani workers
- Czech MP alleges during parliamentary debate on welfare bill that incest is part of Romani culture, open racism on the floor of the lower house
- Roma Lives Matter demo in Czech capital hears eyewitness testimony that Stanislav Tomáš was carried motionless on a stretcher into the ambulance
- Czech Govt Roma Council adopts resolution calling for investigation of the Teplice case and for the public to be informed
- Family of the late Stanislav Tomáš files crime report against the Czech Police through their attorney
- European capitals see unprecedented wave of solidarity with Czech Roma and protests over the death of Stanislav Tomáš
- Romani Rose, head of the Central Council of German Sinti and Roma: Czech Police intervention in Teplice was abhorrent, brutal, and inhumane
- Czech Foreign Affairs Ministry announces its readiness to communicate findings of investigation into Teplice case
- Council of Europe seeks independent, thorough investigation of the death of Romani community member Stanislav Tomáš in Teplice, Czech Republic
- Romani man dies after Czech Police kneel on his neck, they say drugs caused his death. Romani activists see parallels to George Floyd
- Romani child actor from The Painted Bird rejects tv role in the Czech Republic of "bad g*psy child"
- Football hooligans and neo-Nazis blame all Roma for violent crime and march through Czech town, riot police deployed
- Czech lower house committee chooses attorney now facing disciplinary action for making light of racist crime to join public broadcasting board
- Czech court upholds suspended sentence for man who called for non-white first-graders to be gassed to death
- Czech MP who said she "understood" racist death threats against Romani and other non-white children switches parties
- Czech court returns to case of hateful online comments about non-"white" first-graders, but witnesses fail to appear
- Czech court returns to case of hate speech online targeting non-"white" first-graders
- Czech Regional Court returns online hate speech case about death threats against first-graders to lower court, more evidence needed
- Czech court overturns acquittal for author of racist online comments, prosecution will continue
- Czech prosecutor appeals after court acquits online hater of saying dark-skinned first-graders should be gassed to death
- Czech principal says politicians forgot about her school after death threats were made against it last year
- Czech school targeted with hate over its non-white first-graders last year receives donation of laptop computers
- Greece: Romani girl caught in sliding doors dies due to shocking indifference of bystanders, her family sees it as racism
- Czech Police charge dozens of online haters for attacking medical workers as Facebook blocks French and Italian accounts campaigning against vaccination with violence
- Controversial Romani figure appears with Czech extremists opposing measures to control the pandemic
- Czech court gives suspended sentence to woman who threatened to burn down police station in the aftermath of the death of Stanislav Tomáš
- Pope Francis receives Romani footballers, including Jaroslav Horváth and Lukáš Pulko of the Czech Republic, ahead of friendly match
- Czech MMA fighter Cverna challenges bodybuilder who insulted Romani people
- Czech MMA fighter exploits media attention of his win to insult Romani people, then claims he is "not a racist"
- Director of the Museum of Romani Culture schools Czech senator in debate
- Czech Foreign Minister: Whatever is a crime offline in terms of hate speech must be considered a crime online as well
- Czech prosecutor finds livestreamed remarks made in pub about "stabbing" politician rise to the level of a misdemeanor only
- Czech lower house to change leadership, the president and one vice-president will be women, ultranationalist welfare chauvinist is out
- Czech court hands down seven suspended sentences against members of neo-Nazi group after trial that lasted 11 years